What effect, if any, did giving control of the energy industry to the government under Putin have?

Giving control of the energy industry to the government under Putin had several effects.

1. Consolidation of power: By bringing energy companies under government control, Putin was able to exert more influence and control over these crucial sectors of the economy. This allowed him to consolidate power and strengthen his grip on the country.

2. Increase in state revenues: The state-owned energy companies became significant sources of revenue for the government, helping to boost the economy and fund various projects and initiatives.

3. Increased geopolitical leverage: Russia's control over its energy resources, particularly natural gas, gave the country significant leverage in its dealings with other countries, especially those dependent on Russian energy exports. This allowed Putin to use energy as a tool for political influence and manipulation.

4. Lack of competition and innovation: State control of the energy industry stifled competition and innovation in the sector, as government-owned companies were less incentivized to improve efficiency or develop new technologies.

5. Corruption and inefficiency: State control of the energy industry also led to issues of corruption and inefficiency, with government officials and bureaucrats using their positions for personal gain and mismanagement of resources.

Overall, giving control of the energy industry to the government under Putin had both positive and negative effects, with the consolidation of power, increased state revenues, and geopolitical leverage being balanced by a lack of competition, corruption, and inefficiency.