PROMPT 1: Compare and contrast the experiences of two young people in this novel. How are they similar? How are they different? How does Woodson use the similarities and/or differences to emphasize something important about society? Amari and Haley “Harbor Me” by woodosn
In Jacqueline Woodson's novel "Harbor Me," the experiences of two young people, Amari and Haley, provide contrasting yet interconnected perspectives that shed light on important societal issues. While both characters face adversity, their backgrounds and responses to their circumstances highlight the systemic challenges faced by marginalized communities, ultimately emphasizing the need for empathy and understanding in society.
Amari and Haley share certain similarities in their experiences. Both come from marginalized backgrounds, as Amari is a young Black girl who recently migrated to the United States from Honduras, while Haley is a biracial girl with a learning disability. Both girls have had to navigate a society that often labels them and dismisses their identity or struggles.
Despite these overlapping experiences, Amari and Haley also showcase notable differences. Amari's journey is characterized by the challenges of migration and adapting to a new culture. She experiences firsthand the complexities of immigration policies, language barriers, and discrimination due to her race and accent. On the other hand, Haley's struggles revolve around her learning disability, which leads her to feel isolated and misunderstood by her teachers and peers.
Woodson skillfully uses these similarities and differences to emphasize the broader societal issues at play in their respective experiences. Through Amari, the author highlights the complexities and injustices faced by immigrants in America. This is particularly relevant in the current political climate, where immigration policies and xenophobia continue to impact countless individuals seeking a better life. By centering Amari's story, Woodson encourages readers to develop empathy and understanding towards those who are marginalized due to their national origin.
Similarly, through Haley's perspective, Woodson sheds light on the challenges faced by individuals with learning disabilities and the lack of support within educational systems. The author presents a critique of a society that often fails to provide adequate resources and accommodations for students with learning differences, perpetuating feelings of isolation and inadequacy. This portrayal serves as a call to action to address the issues faced by students like Haley and advocate for inclusive education.
Additionally, the friendship between Amari and Haley serves as a powerful symbol of unity and the potential for healing within society. Despite their different backgrounds and struggles, the girls find solace in each other's company and support one another through their shared experiences. Woodson emphasizes the importance of fostering connections and empathy across social divisions, highlighting the potential for collective healing and social change.
In "Harbor Me," Jacqueline Woodson skillfully compares and contrasts the experiences of Amari and Haley to illuminate the societal challenges faced by marginalized communities. By drawing attention to the struggles of immigrants and individuals with learning disabilities, the author encourages readers to develop empathy and understanding, fosters calls to action, and emphasizes the potential for unity and collective healing within society.