PROMPT 1: Compare and contrast the experiences of two young people in this novel. How are they similar? How are they different? How does Woodson use the similarities and/or differences to emphasize something important about society? Amari and Haley
In Jacqueline Woodson's novel "Amari and the Night Brothers," the experiences of two young people, Amari and Haley, are compared and contrasted to highlight important aspects of society. While they both navigate a world of supernatural secrets and danger, their circumstances and reactions differ, shedding light on systemic issues and resilience.
Amari and Haley are similar in their discovery of a hidden world beyond their ordinary lives. Amari, a Black girl from a low-income neighborhood, finds herself recruited into a secret organization called the Bureau of Supernatural Affairs after her brother goes missing. Similarly, Haley, a confident white girl from a privileged background, stumbles upon the magical realm within the same organization. This shared experience of uncovering a hidden truth shows how anyone, regardless of their background, can confront extraordinary circumstances.
However, the two protagonists also face different challenges due to their contrasting backgrounds. Amari encounters various forms of discrimination, both within the Bureau and in the broader society it represents. Racism permeates her experiences, as she is often underestimated or overlooked by her peers and superiors due to her race and social status. In contrast, Haley, although initially teased for her wealth, does not face systemic discrimination. This disparity in how society treats the two characters contributes to Woodson's critique of a system that privileges certain individuals based on race and class.
Woodson uses the similarities and differences between Amari and Haley to emphasize the importance of solidarity and allyship in the face of systemic injustice. As the two girls form a bond, their friendship becomes a beacon of hope and resistance against prejudice. Despite their different backgrounds, they support and understand each other's struggles, ultimately challenging the existing power dynamics within the Bureau. Through their unity, Woodson highlights the possibility of overcoming societal divisions and fighting injustice through solidarity.
Moreover, the contrasting experiences of Amari and Haley underscore the significance of amplifying marginalized voices. By centering Amari's narrative and exploring her struggles, Woodson sheds light on the challenges faced by Black girls and the importance of representation in a society still grappling with deep-rooted biases. Amari's journey serves as a mirror for readers, fostering empathy and understanding of the realities faced by marginalized communities.
In "Amari and the Night Brothers," Woodson skillfully compares and contrasts the experiences of Amari and Haley, highlighting important social issues. Their shared journey of discovery, along with their divergent encounters with discrimination, emphasizes the need for solidarity and amplification of marginalized voices. Woodson's use of these similarities and differences creates a nuanced portrayal of society and fosters empathy in her readers.