Does Schaffer truly believe that the value of a Sherpa life can be stated in numbers? Why or why not?
Schaffer does not believe that the value of a Sherpa life can be stated in numbers. In his essay "The Virtue of Philanthropy," Schaffer argues that attempting to assign a numerical value to human life is a reductionist and dehumanizing approach. He suggests that each individual life is unique and intrinsically valuable, and cannot be reduced to mere numbers or economic calculations.
For Schaffer, the value of a Sherpa life goes beyond monetary or economic worth. He emphasizes the importance of recognizing the dignity and worth of individuals irrespective of their economic contributions. Sherpas, as mountain guides and support staff, play a vital role in mountaineering expeditions in the Himalayas and contribute significantly to the success and safety of climbers. However, Schaffer argues that their value should not solely be measured by their economic productivity or the money they generate for the tourism industry.
Instead, Schaffer emphasizes the need to appreciate the intrinsic worth and humanity of Sherpas. He believes that their cultural heritage, unique skills, and personal experiences make their lives inherently valuable. The subjective aspects of their lives, such as their relationships, aspirations, and overall well-being, should also be considered when attempting to understand their value.
Therefore, Schaffer's perspective suggests that the value of a Sherpa life cannot be effectively expressed or reduced to numbers alone. The complexity and richness of their existence surpasses mere quantitative assessments.