The following question references the novel The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane.
When Henry returns to the regiment, he explains that he received a bullet wound to the head so he won't have to admit that he deserted in battle. How do you think the soldiers would have reacted had he told them the truth now that they had all been involved in fighting? Do you think the fact that Henry returned would have made them more understanding or more likely to punish him?
It is difficult to definitively predict how the soldiers would have reacted had Henry told them the truth about deserting in battle. However, we can examine a few possible scenarios based on their experiences and the nature of war camaraderie.
1. Understanding and Empathy: The soldiers may have understood the fear and panic that drove Henry to desert. Having experienced the horrors of battle themselves, they might have empathized with Henry's momentary lapse in courage. They could have recognized that fear can lead individuals to make irrational decisions. In this case, they may have been more forgiving and sympathetic towards Henry, welcoming him back into the fold.
2. Anger and Resentment: On the other hand, the soldiers might have reacted with anger and resentment upon learning that Henry deserted in the midst of fighting. They may equate desertion with cowardice and betrayal, viewing it as an act that put their lives at risk. Having witnessed the sacrifices and bravery of their comrades, the soldiers may have been less understanding and more likely to punish him for his actions.
3. Mixed Reactions: It is also plausible that the soldiers' reactions could have varied. Some may have sympathized with Henry's fear and struggles, while others might have been less forgiving. This could have led to a divided response within the regiment, with some soldiers expressing understanding and others advocating punishment.
Ultimately, the soldiers' reactions would depend on the specific dynamics within the regiment, the personalities of the soldiers, and their individual experiences in battle. It is possible that Henry's return could have sparked a range of emotions and differing opinions on how to handle his desertion.