What claim was Alexander Hamilton making in his speesh a federalist at the constitutional convention
direct democracies are the purest form of government
direct democracies become corrupt by tyrants
the unitd states is too big to be democracy
ancient democracies worked but are unworkable today
The claim that Alexander Hamilton was making in his speech as a Federalist at the Constitutional Convention was that direct democracies become corrupt by tyrants.
The claim that Alexander Hamilton was making in his speech as a Federalist at the Constitutional Convention was that ancient democracies worked but are unworkable today.
In order to determine the claim that Alexander Hamilton was making in his speech at the Constitutional Convention, we can consult historical records and primary sources such as his actual speech or writings. Alexander Hamilton was a Federalist, which means he advocated for a stronger federal government and supported the proposed United States Constitution.
Based on his beliefs as a Federalist, the claim most closely aligned with Hamilton's views would be that "direct democracies become corrupt by tyrants." The Federalists, including Hamilton, were concerned about the potential pitfalls of a pure democracy, where the people have direct decision-making power, fearing that it could lead to mob rule or the rise of populist leaders. Instead, they favored a representative democracy, where citizens elect representatives to make decisions on their behalf.
To delve deeper into Hamilton's specific beliefs on this matter, it would be advisable to study his writings, such as "The Federalist Papers," particularly papers authored by Hamilton, such as Federalist No. 9 or Federalist No. 10. These papers might provide further elucidation on his stance.