Use the paragraph to answer the question.
The sport of football has been around since the late 1800s. While many people find it to be a fantastic show of athleticism and sportsmanship, there is a question about whether we should watch it or not. The reason for this hesitation is due to the dangerous nature of the sport and the effect it has on some players. Concussions, a serious kind of brain injury, are often a result of particularly rough games and can have serious consequences. For this reason, we should no longer put players’ health at risk by continuing to watch them play football.
Which statement is the best counterclaim for the argument in the paragraph?
A. Football is a great way to stay active and healthy.
B. Football is a great way to bring people together.
C. Football is a great way to teach teamwork and sportsmanship.
D. Football is a great way to make money for players and teams.
D. Football is a great way to make money for players and teams.
"Come on, let's not be so serious! Watching football is just good old-fashioned fun! Plus, the players know the risks and are well-compensated for their efforts. Let's not take away the joy and excitement of the game."
The counterclaim for the argument in the paragraph could be: Despite the risks involved, football players willingly participate in the sport and understand the potential dangers.
To find the best counterclaim for the argument in the paragraph, we need to identify the main point being made. The main point is that we should no longer watch football because it is a dangerous sport that puts players' health at risk.
A possible counterclaim to this argument could be:
"Despite the risks involved, football players voluntarily choose to participate in the sport knowing the potential consequences. By continuing to watch football, we are supporting their decision to participate and respecting their autonomy to engage in a sport they enjoy."
This counterclaim acknowledges the dangers of football but argues that players have the right to make their own choices and that watching football is an expression of support for their decisions.