We learn a lot more about Holden and Jane’s relationship in Chapter 11. Take some time to think and write about what it means. What does it tell us about Holden?
(catcher in the rye)
To understand what Holden and Jane's relationship in Chapter 11 tells us about Holden, we first need to examine the events and interactions that occur between them. In this chapter of "The Catcher in the Rye" by J.D. Salinger, Holden spends time reminiscing about his childhood friendship with Jane Gallagher, a girl he was once close to. Here are some key points to consider when analyzing the significance of their relationship:
1. Emotional connection: Throughout the chapter, Holden expresses a deep emotional connection to Jane. He repeatedly mentions how he enjoys talking to her on the phone and recalls special moments they shared, such as playing checkers and seeing a movie together. This suggests that Holden holds a genuine affection for Jane.
2. Protective instinct: Holden mentions that Jane used to keep her kings in the back row in checkers, which indicates her vulnerability and innocence. This detail highlights Holden's protective instinct toward Jane. He worries about her well-being and believes that many people, including her stepfather, treat her poorly. This concern reveals Holden's compassionate nature and his desire to shield those who are vulnerable.
3. Symbolic significance: Jane's relationship with Holden holds symbolic meaning throughout the novel. Holden perceives her as innocent and unaffected by the corruption and phoniness of the adult world. He sees her as someone who can maintain her integrity and authenticity amidst societal pressures. Holden's admiration for Jane's innocence represents his yearning to preserve and protect the purity he sees in her.
4. Loss and longing: In Chapter 11, Holden tries to call Jane but hesitates and doesn't follow through. This hesitation suggests his fear of confronting the changes that might have occurred in their relationship since they last interacted. It also demonstrates Holden's struggle with accepting the loss of innocence and connection as he transitions into adulthood. His longing for the way things used to be reveals his difficulty in letting go of the past and facing the uncertainties of the future.
Overall, Jane's relationship with Holden symbolizes his longing for genuine connections and his desire to protect innocence in a world he perceives as superficial and corrupt. Through his thoughts and reflections on their relationship, we gain insight into Holden's inner turmoil and his yearning for authenticity and emotional connection.