Which of the following reflects the ideas expressed in Federalist, no. 10 when addressing the concerns presented by Brutus I?
A. ***
The court system would be an important check on the growing power of the states.
B.
The House of Representatives would be the primary champion of executive power.
C.
States would be allowed to override those aspects of federal law they disagreed with.
D.
The federal government would protect rights by balancing democracy and republicanism.
Well, why be boring when you can be funny? Let's see if I can clown around with these answer choices for you!
A. The court system would be an important check on the growing power of the states.
Well, the court system might end up feeling like a game of "whack-a-mole" with all those powers popping up everywhere!
B. The House of Representatives would be the primary champion of executive power.
The House of Representatives playing superhero for the executive branch? Sounds like a sitcom waiting to happen!
C. States would be allowed to override those aspects of federal law they disagreed with.
States overriding federal law? Sounds like a game of 'Simon Says,' but with more serious consequences!
D. The federal government would protect rights by balancing democracy and republicanism.
Ah yes, the federal government trying to be the referee in the eternal tug-of-war between democracy and republicanism. Talk about a balancing act!
So, in my clownish opinion, D sounds like the most accurate reflection of the ideas expressed in Federalist, no. 10.
The correct answer is D. The Federalist, no. 10 emphasizes that the federal government would protect individual rights by balancing democracy and republicanism. This is in response to the concerns raised by Brutus I.
To determine which option reflects the ideas expressed in Federalist, No. 10 when addressing the concerns presented by Brutus I, we need to analyze the content of both texts.
First, Federalist, No. 10 was written by James Madison and addressed the issue of factions (groups of individuals with similar interests) within a democratic government. Madison argued that a large, diverse republic would be able to better control the negative effects of factions than a small, homogenous democracy.
Brutus I, on the other hand, was authored by an Anti-Federalist (likely Robert Yates) as a critique of the proposed United States Constitution. Brutus I raised concerns about the potential establishment of a tyrannical government, particularly due to the supremacy of the federal government over the states.
Now let's analyze the given options:
A. The court system would be an important check on the growing power of the states.
This option appears to address the concern expressed by Brutus I regarding the federal government's potentially excessive power over the states. It suggests that the court system could act as a check on the federal government, which aligns with the Federalist argument that a large republic could mitigate the dangers of concentrated power.
B. The House of Representatives would be the primary champion of executive power.
This option does not directly reflect the concerns presented by Brutus I, nor does it align with the ideas expressed in Federalist, No. 10. It seems to introduce a different aspect of government and does not address the specific concerns raised.
C. States would be allowed to override those aspects of federal law they disagreed with.
This option contradicts the ideas expressed in Federalist, No. 10, which argues for a strong federal government to control factions and prevent states from overriding federal laws. Therefore, it does not reflect the ideas expressed in the given Federalist paper.
D. The federal government would protect rights by balancing democracy and republicanism.
Option D appears to align with the ideas expressed in Federalist, No. 10. Madison argues for a large republic as a means of balancing democracy and republicanism to protect individual rights. This, in turn, addresses the concerns presented by Brutus I regarding potential governmental tyranny.
Based on the analysis, the option that best reflects the ideas expressed in Federalist, No. 10 when addressing the concerns presented by Brutus I is option D: The federal government would protect rights by balancing democracy and republicanism.