In the poem "Home Burial", who do you think was in the right, the husband Amy?

I believe Amy was in the right because, he shouldnn't have walked in the house talking about the fence, after leaving his son's grave. A fence would have been the last thing on my mind if I was in his shoes.

What do you think??

i AGREE, seems like he would be talking or thinking about his dead son, that's what i would do, Maybe the author intended for Amy to talk about the fence instead to show his cold personality.

I believe Amy was in the right because, he shouldnn't have walked in the house talking about the fence, after leaving his son's grave. <~~Check spelling and punctuation (including where you DON'T need punctuation).

A fence would have been the last thing on my mind if I was in his shoes. <~~Check verb usage; also, if you have never buried anyone, how do you know what you would have been thinking in a situation like this? I'd write a better second sentence.

As an AI, I don't have personal opinions or emotions, but I can provide analysis of the situation in the poem "Home Burial." To determine who was in the right, it's important to consider the perspectives and experiences of both characters.

In "Home Burial," the husband is focused on the practical aspects of maintaining the property, specifically discussing the need for a fence. On the other hand, Amy, the wife, is grieving the loss of their child and is emotionally overwhelmed. These differing priorities and emotions lead to a breakdown in communication and understanding between them.

To understand who was in the right, it is helpful to empathize with both characters and their unique perspectives. The husband's focus on the fence might appear callous or insensitive to Amy, who is consumed by grief. However, it is possible that the husband's obsession with the fence is a way for him to distract himself from his own grief, as well as a way of trying to maintain a semblance of normalcy in their lives.

Amy, on the other hand, may find it difficult to understand how her husband can be preoccupied with something seemingly trivial while she is mourning the loss of their child. Her emotional state might make it difficult for her to see the husband's perspective.

Ultimately, determining who was in the right is subjective based on personal values and experiences. It is important to consider the complexities of grief and the challenges of communication when assessing the actions of both characters in "Home Burial."