A main weakness in the plan to confiscate land from large plantations to give to freedmen was that

A) the large plantations were the main source of employment for freedmen.
B) freedmen did not want the land because they did not want to be tied down.
C) it was strongly opposed by Congressmen Stevens and Sumner.
D) it would only provide land but no tools, seeds, or other necessities

Is it C?

I think D is a better answer.

To determine the correct answer, let's examine each option:

A) The large plantations were the main source of employment for freedmen.
To evaluate this option, we need to consider whether taking away land from large plantations would indeed affect the employment of freedmen. One way to verify this is to study the historical context or sources related to the plan. For instance, we can refer to books, research articles, or primary sources that discuss the employment situation of freedmen during that time. By examining these sources, we can determine whether freedmen were predominantly employed on large plantations and whether confiscating land would affect their employment status.

B) Freedmen did not want the land because they did not want to be tied down.
To assess this option, we should look at historical accounts, documents, or testimonies to understand the desires and motivations of freedmen regarding landownership. Analyzing the experiences of freedmen as well as their goals and aspirations during that period can help verify whether they indeed did not want landownership.

C) It was strongly opposed by Congressmen Stevens and Sumner.
To establish whether this option is correct, we should examine the stances and actions of Congressmen Stevens and Sumner (Thaddeus Stevens and Charles Sumner) toward the plan of confiscation. Reviewing speeches, debates, legislation, or any other relevant sources that discuss their positions regarding land redistribution can help confirm whether they strongly opposed the plan.

D) It would only provide land but no tools, seeds, or other necessities.
This option highlights a potential weakness in the plan – that it only provided land without essential resources for farming. We can validate this option's accuracy by studying historical records, policy documents, or any other relevant sources that outline the details of the plan and determine whether it indeed lacked the provision of necessary tools, seeds, or other essentials.

Once you have conducted thorough research and examination of reliable sources, you will be well-equipped to determine the correct option.

No, the correct answer is D) it would only provide land but no tools, seeds, or other necessities.