we are reading the scarlet letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne. can you please tell me why Arthur Dimmesdale is the greatest sinner in the book and give examples and quotes (for quotes include what chapter it was found in) thanks!
You should go to www.sparknotes.com/lit and read the section on character analysis. As for examples and quotes, you'll need to find them on your own -- you have the book, I hope! I don't.
Please re-post with what you have come up with if you wish someone to critique your work.
=)
Why is his sin greater than the other members of the church and community? That is a nice debate on morality...is the silent culprit more guilty than those who besmirch the visible culprit?
To explain why Arthur Dimmesdale is often considered the greatest sinner in "The Scarlet Letter," it is important to understand the context and events of the story. While I cannot provide specific quotes and examples, I can guide you on how to analyze the character and find relevant evidence in the book.
Dimmesdale's role as the town's minister is accompanied by a sense of hypocrisy. Unlike Hester Prynne, who openly displays her sin by wearing the scarlet letter, Dimmesdale conceals his involvement and suffers privately. This concealment and the internal torment he experiences can be seen as a form of hypocrisy and a betrayal of his pastoral responsibilities.
One way to find examples and quotes that support this interpretation is to closely examine Dimmesdale's behavior and actions throughout the story. Look for instances where he preaches about sin and morality while secretly struggling with his own guilt. Pay attention to his interactions with other characters, such as Hester and Pearl, and how his hidden sin impacts their lives.
Additionally, consider the effect of Dimmesdale's guilt on his physical and mental health. Hawthorne often describes his deteriorating condition and the toll it takes on him, highlighting the consequences of his hidden sin. Look for passages that depict Dimmesdale's internal struggle and the ways in which it affects his well-being.
By analyzing Dimmesdale's actions, interactions, and internal conflict, you will be able to identify quotes and examples that illustrate why he is perceived as the greatest sinner in the book. Remember to note down the chapter numbers where you find the relevant evidence, as this will support your analysis.