Do you find that Claude Monet painting

at the edge of a wood by John Singer Sargent depicts good contrast with asymmetrical balance or would Van Gogh's Starry Night be a better choice.

Please re-read what you posted. Do you understand why only you can answer this?

What do YOU think?

http://www.tate.org.uk/art/artworks/sargent-claude-monet-painting-by-the-edge-of-a-wood-n04103

http://uploads2.wikipaintings.org/images/vincent-van-gogh/the-starry-night-1889(1).jpg

Thanks I got it. I feel that Starry Night would be the better choice for me in terms of contrast with asymmetrical balance.

To determine whether Claude Monet's painting, "At the Edge of a Wood" by John Singer Sargent, depicts good contrast with asymmetrical balance, or if Vincent van Gogh's "Starry Night" would be a better choice, we need to analyze the artistic elements and principles of both paintings.

1. Contrast: Contrast refers to the juxtaposition of different elements in a composition, such as colors, values, textures, or shapes. To assess the contrast, examine how the artists have used these elements to create visual impact or emphasis.

To evaluate the contrast in Monet's painting, analyze the colors, values, and textures. Look for areas where light and dark tones are placed next to each other or where vibrant colors contrast with more muted ones.

Regarding van Gogh's "Starry Night," observe the contrast between the swirling, dynamic brushstrokes, and the dramatic tonal changes. Pay attention to areas where strong contrasts in colors, shapes, and values create a sense of depth and movement.

2. Asymmetrical Balance: Asymmetrical balance, also known as informal balance, refers to achieving equilibrium in a composition without mirrored or symmetrical elements. It involves distributing visual weight unevenly to create a harmonious composition.

In Monet's painting, analyze the arrangement of elements, such as trees, foliage, foreground, background, or any prominent focal point, to see if they are balanced in a way that feels visually appealing despite lacking symmetry.

In the case of van Gogh's "Starry Night," assess how the different elements are distributed across the canvas, such as the stars, moon, cypress tree, village, and sky. Determine if the composition feels balanced despite the absence of symmetry.

By conducting this comparative analysis, you can ascertain which painting exhibits good contrast with asymmetrical balance. However, it is important to note that art appreciation is subjective, and personal preferences might vary. Therefore, exploring the artworks yourself can provide a more informed judgment based on your individual taste and interpretation.