Polaris is also known as the North Star. Atares has the same apperent magnatude as Polaris. Explain how this can be given that the H-R diagram places it in a different size and luminosity category?
Please see the answer you've already received.
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1205707820
To understand why Polaris and Atares can have the same apparent magnitude but be placed in different size and luminosity categories on the Hertzsprung-Russell (H-R) diagram, we need to consider a few key factors.
Firstly, let's clarify the concepts of apparent magnitude and size/luminosity categories on the H-R diagram.
Apparent magnitude: This refers to how bright a star appears to an observer on Earth. It is a measure of the star's brightness as seen from a specific distance.
Size/luminosity categories on the H-R diagram: The H-R diagram classifies stars based on their luminosity (actual energy output) and size (radius). It categorizes stars into different regions, such as main sequence, giants, or supergiants, based on these factors.
Now, let's address how Polaris and Atares can have the same apparent magnitude but different positions on the H-R diagram.
The apparent magnitude of a star is determined by factors such as its intrinsic luminosity, distance from Earth, and any intervening objects that may affect its brightness. In the case of Polaris and Atares, while they may have similar apparent magnitudes, their intrinsic luminosities and distances from Earth are different.
Polaris, also known as the North Star, belongs to the spectral class F7Ib-II and is classified as a yellow supergiant. It is about 2,000 times brighter than our Sun but has a relatively small radius compared to other supergiants.
Atares, on the other hand, is a red supergiant star located in the constellation Scorpius. It has a lower surface temperature than Polaris, which makes it appear redder. Due to its lower temperature and larger radius, Atares is classified as a red supergiant on the H-R diagram.
While Polaris and Atares may have similar apparent magnitudes, their positions on the H-R diagram differ because their intrinsic luminosities and sizes are distinct. They belong to different size and luminosity categories due to variations in factors such as temperature, radius, and evolutionary stages.
To determine specific values, such as actual luminosity and sizes of these stars, astronomers rely on additional measurements, such as parallax, spectroscopy, and modeling techniques. These measurements help to characterize stars more accurately, allowing astronomers to study their properties and understand their positions on the H-R diagram.