business law

CASE PROBLEM: Three brothers inherited a small paper-supply business from their father, who had operated the business as a sole proprietorship. The brothers decided to incorporate under the name Miwa Corp. and retained an attorney to draw up the necessary documents. The attorney drew up the papers and had the brothers sign them but neglected to send the application for a corporate charter to the secretary of state's office. The brothers assumed that all necessary legal work had been taken care of, and they proceeded to do business as Miwa Corp. One day, a Miwa Corp. employee was delivering a carton of paper supplies to one of Miwa's customers. On the way to the customer's office, the employee negligently ran a red light and caused a car accident. Harman, the driver of the other vehicle, was injured as a result and sued Miwa Corp. for damages. When Harman learned that no state charter had ever been issued to Miwa Corp., he sued each of the brothers personally for damages. Can the brothers avoid personal liability for the tort of their employee? Explain.

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 73
asked by Bryan
  1. Please post your ideas on this problem, and someone here will be happy to comment on your ideas.

    =)

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
  2. this is what i think

    In this case Miwa Corp. probably has de facto status which would mean that the existence of the corporation can only be challenged by the state, not by Harman because he is a third party. There are three elements required for de facto status (this is all coming from page 778). There must be a state statute under which the corporation can be validly incorporated, and although the case does not specifically say which state Miwa Corp. is in there are state statutes in every state that will allow them to be validly incorporated. The second is that the parties must have made a good faith attempt to comply with the statute. By hiring the attorney to take care of all the details and signing the state charter, the brothers have made a good faith attempt to comply. They did not know that the attorney had not sent the papers. Lastly, the enterprise must already have undertaken to do business as a corporation, and clearly they have been operating as Miwa Corp. not knowing that their corporate charter was not sent in.

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
    posted by Bryan

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Math: is it? is it not?

    Is this math problem hard? - There are 12 brothers living in a mansion. Six brothers are sitting in a rectangular kind of table. Six other brothers stood around them. They all have ten huge backpacks. Each backpack has 8 large

    asked by Losa on September 24, 2013
  2. Mircoeconomics: Elasticity

    Please help! I have a mid-term test in a couple of minutes... -------------- If the demand for some good fluctuates, but supply is constant, then which of the following combinations would generally yield the greatest quantity

    asked by Anonymous on October 4, 2008
  3. Physics

    an electrical appliance take 5A when operated on a 220V supply. If the appliance is operated from 6am - 6am at 10kobo per KWh how much will d nepa officer collect?

    asked by Black mamba on August 22, 2019
  4. Microeconomics

    Can you show graphically the presence of externalities for example in the case of research and development expenditures? Also is this type of externality referred to as the generic case? thanks.... I don't know what you mean by

    asked by AliceP on November 8, 2006
  5. Math

    You will need the following info to solve the problem: You can cover a sheet of paper with 6 $100 bills There are 500 sheets of paper in 1 ream There are 10 reams in 1 carton Imagine that you have inherited $1 million . The bank

    asked by Ruth on February 3, 2012
  6. Finance

    You will need the following info to solve the problem: You can cover a sheet of paper with 6 $100 bills There are 500 sheets of paper in 1 ream There are 10 reams in 1 carton Imagine that you have inherited $1 million . The bank

    asked by Ruth on February 3, 2012
  7. HUMAN CAPITAL, PHYSICAL CAPITAL, which is more IMP

    I am going to write a paper about that, my view is human capital is more important, but don't know what should say in my paper for that.... Anyone any ideas? what do you think which one is more important? WHY? are you writing that

    asked by MACROECON on June 29, 2007
  8. Math

    A math problem asks when two brothers will have saved the same amount of money. When Marta writes and solves the equation, her final step is 3 = 7. Assuming Marta has done everything correctly, how should she interpret this

    asked by Sophia on August 29, 2019
  9. English

    Why did Wiesel call his father’s knife and spoon “the inheritance”? The utensils were worth money to the doctors It was the only thing of value that his father had. The knife and spoon were inherited from his father’s

    asked by Bri on November 18, 2017
  10. English

    Why did Wiesel call his father’s knife and spoon “the inheritance”? The utensils were worth money to the doctors It was the only thing of value that his father had. The knife and spoon were inherited from his father’s

    asked by Bri on November 18, 2017

More Similar Questions