Second Grade Classroom Scenario
As Miss Gibson’s second graders break out into their learning centers, a scuffle starts in the writing center. Two boys are shoving and pushing each other. Miss Gibson stops the class and yells, “Boys stop!” Instead of stopping, the boys continue to shove and push each other. Aaron, the most vocal of the two boys, starts yelling, “Tony took the red marker!” Tony denies it. Soon the boys are shouting at each other. The rest of the class stands around watching and no one has started working in their center.
Answer the following questions in paragraph form in relation to the scenario:
2. How well did the teacher handle himself or herself in the scenario? What student–teacher interactions worked well and what did not work? How would you handle the situation?
4. What conflicts did you observe in this classroom? What conflict resolution methods could you use to resolve the conflicts in this classroom? Are there any peer mediation methods that you could use in this scenario? Yes, both students
Tenth Grade Classroom Scenario
The bell has rung and Mr. Dunn’s tenth grade math class has settled into their seats. “Good morning! Let’s begin by having everyone pass their homework to the front of the class.” Tom walks into class 5 minutes late. Mr. Dunn asks, “Tom, do you have your homework?” Tom looks down at the floor when he answers, “No, I didn’t finish it.” Mr. Dunn asks, “Why not? You knew it was due today, right?” Tom just shrugs. Mr. Dunn asks the rest of the class, “Who else did not turn in their homework today?” Pamela did not do her homework, but is afraid to raise her hand. Mr. Dunn says, “Good job, class! I appreciate everyone who worked hard to get their work turned in on time.” Daniel chimes in, “Which is everyone except Tom!” The class laughs. Tom angrily gets out of his chair and storms out of the room as he says, “I’m sick of this stupid class.”
2. How well did the teacher handle himself or herself in the scenario? What student–teacher interactions worked well and what did not work? How would you handle the situation?
Please note that no one here will do your work for you. However, we will be happy to read over what YOU THINK and make suggestions and/or corrections.
Please post what you think.
2. In the second grade scenario, Miss Gibson did not handle the situation well. Yelling and shouting at the boys did not effectively stop their behavior, and it caused the rest of the class to become distracted and not work on their centers. Instead of yelling, Miss Gibson could have calmly intervened, physically separating the boys to ensure their safety. She could have then addressed the situation by asking them to explain what happened, listening to both sides, and facilitating a discussion to find a resolution. Regarding the conflict between Aaron and Tony, Miss Gibson could have used techniques such as restating the problem, brainstorming solutions, and encouraging empathy to help the boys resolve their conflict. If the conflict persisted, she could consider implementing peer mediation, where trained student mediators help facilitate a resolution between the students involved.
2. In the tenth grade scenario, Mr. Dunn did not handle the situation well either. By immediately questioning Tom about his missing homework in front of the whole class, Mr. Dunn embarrassed him and created an atmosphere where other students felt comfortable mocking him. This resulted in Tom storming out of the room in anger. Instead, Mr. Dunn could have addressed the issue privately with Tom, expressing understanding and concern for his lack of completed homework. He could have asked if there was anything going on that was preventing Tom from completing his work and offered assistance in catching up. Additionally, Mr. Dunn could have refrained from publicly praising the students who turned in their homework on time and instead focused on encouraging all students to complete their assignments. This would have created a more supportive atmosphere and lessened the likelihood of students mocking each other.
In the second grade classroom scenario, Miss Gibson did not handle the situation well. Yelling at the boys to stop did not effectively address the issue, as they continued to shove and push each other. Additionally, allowing the boys to shout at each other and escalate the situation further was not productive. The lack of intervention and guidance from the teacher caused the rest of the class to stand around instead of engaging in their learning centers.
To handle this situation, it would be more effective for Miss Gibson to approach the two boys calmly and firmly, separating them if needed. She should address each boy individually and give them the opportunity to express their side of the story. By actively listening to both boys and acknowledging their feelings, she can validate their experiences and provide guidance for conflict resolution. It would be important for Miss Gibson to establish classroom rules and expectations for appropriate behavior, and to model and reinforce positive communication and problem-solving skills.
In the tenth grade classroom scenario, Mr. Dunn did not handle himself well. Instead of addressing Tom's lateness and missing homework privately, he singled him out in front of the whole class. This resulted in Tom feeling embarrassed and humiliated, leading to his angry outburst and storming out of the room.
To handle this situation, it would be more appropriate for Mr. Dunn to speak with Tom privately after class or during a break. He should approach him with empathy and understanding, asking if everything is okay and if there's a reason for his missing homework. It is important to create a safe and supportive environment where students feel comfortable discussing personal challenges or concerns. Mr. Dunn could also address the issue of Tom's lateness more privately and find solutions to help him be more punctual in the future.
In both scenarios, it would be beneficial for the teachers to implement conflict resolution methods. For the second grade classroom, teaching the students about active listening, compromise, and problem-solving strategies can help them navigate conflicts more effectively. Peer mediation methods can also be used, where trained students help facilitate discussions and find solutions. In the tenth grade classroom, encouraging empathy, respect, and understanding among students can significantly reduce conflicts. Implementing restorative practices and promoting open dialogue and reflection can create a more inclusive and supportive learning environment.
In the second grade classroom scenario, Miss Gibson did not handle herself well. When she yelled at the boys to stop, they did not listen to her and continued to engage in the physical altercation. Additionally, when Aaron accused Tony of taking the red marker, Miss Gibson did not effectively address the issue and resolve the conflict between the two boys. Instead, the situation escalated into shouting and chaos, resulting in no one in the class working on their assigned tasks.
To handle this situation, I would recommend the following approach. First, I would calmly and firmly intervene in the physical altercation, separating the two boys and ensuring their safety. Then, I would address each boy individually to understand their side of the story and validate their feelings. By actively listening to both Aaron and Tony, I would aim to find a resolution that satisfies both parties, such as finding another marker for Aaron or mediating a fair solution.
In the tenth grade classroom scenario, Mr. Dunn did not handle himself well. When Tom arrived late and admitted he did not finish his homework, Mr. Dunn immediately questioned him in a confrontational manner, which may have made Tom feel uncomfortable and defensive. Additionally, when Daniel made a remark about Tom in front of the class, Mr. Dunn did not address it, allowing the class to laugh at Tom's expense. This lack of support and empathy could have contributed to Tom's angry outburst and decision to leave the classroom.
To handle this situation, I would approach it differently. Firstly, I would acknowledge Tom's late arrival and missing homework privately, without publicly questioning him about it. This would allow him to save face and not feel humiliated in front of his peers. During a break or after class, I would talk to Tom about his behavior and address his frustration. I would offer support, understanding, and guidance, perhaps suggesting strategies or resources to help him better manage his assignments. It is crucial to create a safe and inclusive classroom environment where students feel supported rather than targeted or ridiculed.