we are doing this debate. i am on the history team. why is history more important than math, art (lit included), social sciences, natural sciences. and what are those subjects' flaws
My favorite example is of the small child who touches a hot stove and learns the real meaning of "hot." This experience teaches him a lesson that he's unlikely to repeat.
When we learn from history, we can avoid repeating past painful experiences.
Think of the wars mankind could have avoided if he'd learned from history.
Here's what one man includes on his website and puts under his signature:
Those who do not know history are doomed to repeat it. But they have no idea they're in a re-run.
That's a slight paraphrase of the original statement, and there are some others that are pretty good, too:
George Santayana:
Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
George Bernard Shaw:
We learn from history that we learn nothing from history.
George Wilhelm Hegel:
What experience and history teach is this -- that people and governments never have learned anything from history, or acted on principles.
(From (Broken Link Removed) )
As an AI, I am here to provide you with information to support your debate, but it's important to note that the importance of each subject can vary depending on individual perspectives and context. That being said, here are some arguments regarding the importance of history compared to other subjects:
1. Understanding the Present: History provides us with a deeper understanding of the events, ideas, and experiences that have shaped our world. By studying history, we can gain insights into current affairs, societal trends, and cultural developments.
To address the flaws of other subjects:
2. Math: While math plays a critical role in various fields, it can sometimes be seen as an abstract subject that may not immediately seem relevant to everyday life. Additionally, some may argue that the rigid problem-solving approach in math can limit creativity and critical thinking.
3. Art (including literature): Art subjects encourage creativity, expression, imagination, and emotional intelligence. However, some might argue that studying art does not provide as direct a practical application as history does in understanding societal and political dynamics.
4. Social Sciences: Social sciences, such as sociology, psychology, and anthropology, help us understand human behavior, societies, and cultures. However, they often rely on empirical research methods that can sometimes limit the subjective human experience, leading to generalizations and oversimplifications.
5. Natural Sciences: Natural sciences like physics, chemistry, and biology allow us to understand the natural world around us and advance technological developments. Nevertheless, these subjects can involve complex theories and technical language that might be challenging for some to grasp, potentially limiting accessibility.
Remember, it is crucial to approach this debate with respect for all subjects, as they each offer unique benefits and contribute to our overall understanding of the world.