In the movie The Shawshank Redemption
how does the prison in the film try to rehabilitate its inmates? Was it sucessful? and provide 3 examples of ways in which the prison (guards) enforce compliance to prison rules, were the enforcemnts necessary or effective, help on these questions would be great
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1322623909
In the movie "The Shawshank Redemption," the prison system attempts to rehabilitate its inmates through a few different methods. While it is open to interpretation whether or not these efforts are entirely successful, they do provide some glimpses of hope and change for certain characters. Here are a few examples:
1. Educational Programs: One way the prison aims to rehabilitate inmates is by offering educational programs. In the film, we see Andy Dufresne (the main character) taking the initiative to establish a prison library, where he helps educate himself and other inmates. This program encourages learning, personal growth, and potentially enhances inmates' chances of finding employment upon release.
2. Vocational Training: Another method employed by the prison is providing vocational training to inmates. For instance, we witness Brooks Hatlen, an elderly prisoner, being assigned various prison jobs over the years. Although the effectiveness of this approach is not explicitly explored, it suggests the prison's attempt to equip inmates with skills that could help them in society after their release.
3. Counseling and Parole Boards: The prison system also incorporates counseling and parole boards as avenues for rehabilitation. These boards review inmates' behaviors and progress while incarcerated to determine whether they are eligible for parole or early release. While these processes may not directly provide rehabilitation programs, they offer the prisoners a chance to convince the board of their change and demonstrate their readiness to rejoin society.
Regarding the enforcement of prison rules by the guards, there are multiple occasions where they employ certain tactics to maintain compliance. Whether these enforcement measures are necessary or effective is subjective, as they highlight the power dynamics within the prison system. Here are three examples:
1. Physical Force: In some instances, guards use physical force to enforce compliance. This can be seen when an inmate is resistant or defiant towards authority. While physical force may serve as a deterrent, it can also breed fear, potentially inhibiting genuine rehabilitation.
2. Solitary Confinement: Solitary confinement is a widely-used method in prisons, including the one portrayed in the movie. In this film, it is shown as a form of punishment for rule-breaking or insubordination. While it is intended to modify behavior, the long-term effects of extended isolation can have detrimental psychological impacts, calling into question its effectiveness.
3. Strict Rules and Surveillance: The prison in the movie implements strict rules and constant surveillance to control the behavior of inmates. Guards actively monitor the prisoners through routine searches and maintaining a visible presence. Such measures aim to deter rule-breaking and maintain order within the facility. However, the strict enforcement of rules might also stifle individuality and hinder inmates' opportunities for personal growth and transformation.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of prison rehabilitation and the necessity of enforcement measures are complex and debated topics. The movie provides insights into some of these aspects, but it is important to acknowledge that real-world prison systems vary widely.