physics in a way

If you break a raw egg, why can't you put it back together?
using relations to entropy and the 2nd law of termodynamics

I am not certain of any physical laws that prohibit it. The 2nd law will require that energy be added in order to make up for the increased entropy when breaking.

One could make the same arguement on folded clothes falling off the bed to the floor, asking why they cant be put back on the bed folded: They can, it requires energy to lift, and energy to refold.

I may not be understanding what you are asking here.

well my physics teacher said the egg couldn't ever be back in its origional form and she said that it has something to do with entropy but i cant figure out what

In general an increase in entropy can be reversed, but it takes energy.

by bieng broken the egg has been changed from a complex state into a simple state of disperse components (entropy) which can never be restored to its former complexity (restated)

Here is an explaination of entropy (lost work) and reversibility.

http://web.mit.edu/16.unified/www/FALL/thermodynamics/notes/node48.html



Your post of what your teacher said reminds me of one of my daughters when she was in the fifth grade (she is 31 now). Diane had told the class about finding a four leaf clover. The science teacher told the class there was no such thing as a four leafed clover, after Diane had made her comment.
Diane came come most upset over it. She spent that afternoon (Friday)and all day Saturday, and most of Sunday on her knees in the yard and field. Monday morning she lay five four leaf clovers on the teachers desk.
The teacher never recanted,but Diane had internal satisfaction. The others in the class never knew about it.
Look at the website I posted below. The key to determining is something is reversible is to ask the question what is allowed to happen to its surroundings.
Natural processes that disperse energy (increase in entropy) cannot be reversed by natural methods. If one is willing to replace the lost energy in that particular system, then it can.

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 117
asked by Ghazi

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. college physics

    a large bedsheet is held verticallyy by two students. A third student who happens to be the star pitcher on the baseball team, throws a raw egg at the sheet. explain why the egg doesn't break when it hits the sheet, regardless of

    asked by sarah on June 1, 2008
  2. physics

    I need to make a holder for a raw egg out of straws so when it is dropped from 8 feet. it will not break I need design ideas.

    asked by Deb on October 8, 2009
  3. Science

    Underline the substance which has a higher water concentration: Raw egg or vinegar Raw egg or salt water

    asked by Ninikothe_Weeb on October 30, 2019
  4. Science

    Underline the substance which has a higher water concentration: Raw egg or vinegar Raw egg or salt water

    asked by Ninikothe_Weeb on October 30, 2019
  5. math

    an real raw egg was dropped from a 20 story height , however it didn't break . How is that possible ? IT LANDED on concreate solid.

    asked by jassica on March 28, 2014
  6. Physics

    You are trying to package a 50g egg so that it won't break after you drop it from a height of 10 meters. You decide to use wood as a nice soft packaging to protect the egg. When the egg hits the ground, the wood "softens" the

    asked by Paige on March 21, 2011
  7. Physics

    If you drop a raw egg on the ground, it will break. If you drop it on a saggy sheet, it does not. Explain in terms of momentum and/or impulse.

    asked by Anonymous on November 6, 2018
  8. physical science

    I was doing an egg experiment that I found on line where you put an egg in white vinegar and the shell softens. It said to leave the egg for seven days. At the end of the fourth day the white of the egg which had already softened

    asked by Austin on February 22, 2008
  9. science

    If you throw an egg against a wall, the egg will break. But if you throw it at the same speed into a sagging sheer, it may not break. Why?

    asked by Emma on October 21, 2007
  10. English

    After we put an egg in a glass, when we add salt, the egg goes up from the bottom. Which of the following expressions is correct. 1. The egg is moving up from the bottom. 2. The egg is floating up from the bottom. 3. The egg is

    asked by rfvv on November 2, 2017

More Similar Questions