Jody says that atonal harmony establishes a harmonic center of gravity. Sean says that atonal harmony doesn't have a harmonic center of gravity. who is correct?
A. Only Jody is correct.
B. Only Sean is correct.
C. Both Jody and Sean are correct.
D. Neither Jody nor Sean is Correct.
I Think it is D. Neither Jody nor Sean is correct.
Which one is the correct answer.
To determine which of Jody and Sean is correct, we need to understand the concept of atonal harmony and its impact on establishing a harmonic center of gravity.
Atonal harmony refers to the absence of a defined key or tonal center in a piece of music. Instead of relying on traditional tonal relationships between chords and notes, atonal music explores different ways of organizing sounds, often with an emphasis on dissonance and unconventional chord progressions.
Based on this understanding, we can evaluate the statements made by Jody and Sean:
Jody says that atonal harmony establishes a harmonic center of gravity. This statement is inconsistent with the nature of atonal music, as it deliberately avoids establishing a tonal center. Therefore, Jody's statement is incorrect.
Sean says that atonal harmony doesn't have a harmonic center of gravity. This statement aligns with the nature of atonal music, which intentionally lacks a tonal center. Therefore, Sean's statement is correct.
Given this analysis, the answer is:
B. Only Sean is correct.
It is important to note that this answer is based on the understanding and definition of atonal harmony as stated. Different interpretations or perspectives may yield different answers.