Dr. Kyle shared the newspaper clipping with his class. "This is an unusual case, but I believe the punishment phase of the trial would have been different in another state. The crime was committed, but the defendant is not in touch with reality most of the time." Dr. Kyle is referring to variations in the definition of mental disorder as: (Points: 5)
a) a deviation from the average.
b) a deviation from the ideal.
c) an inability to function effectively.
d) a legal concept.
I think the answer is B
I disagree.
I think it is B.
kay thanks
wait can it be C?
I think C is correct.
kay Thanks
You're welcome.
This is a complex concept. Insanity is a legal term, indicating that the person was incapable of distinguishing between right and wrong at the time of the act. Many mental disorders would not excuse criminal behavior. I believe the best answer is D.
While all four are definitions of a mental disorder, the correct answer is D.
To determine the correct answer, let's break down the choices and consider Dr. Kyle's statement:
a) a deviation from the average: This choice refers to a statistical understanding of mental disorder, considering it as a deviation from what is considered typical or average. However, Dr. Kyle's statement does not suggest this perspective.
b) a deviation from the ideal: This choice suggests that mental disorder is defined by a deviation from some ideal state. While this idea may be relevant to some discussions of mental health, it is not directly addressed in Dr. Kyle's statement.
c) an inability to function effectively: This choice implies that mental disorder is characterized by an individual's inability to function effectively. Dr. Kyle's statement mentions that the defendant is "not in touch with reality most of the time," which aligns quite closely with the idea of an inability to function effectively.
d) a legal concept: This choice suggests that mental disorder is a legal concept, potentially related to the determination of guilt or punishment in trails. Dr. Kyle's statement mentions how the punishment phase of the trial would have been different in another state, suggesting a connection between mental disorder and the legal system.
Considering Dr. Kyle's statement and the options provided, the most appropriate answer is d) a legal concept.