Choose an ethical approach and explain the steps one should take when a supervisor asks one to perform a lawful, but immoral act
Which ethical approach have you chosen? What would you do?
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1289687456
Consider lying: what do you do when your supervisor tells you to fudge the truth? Sometimes that does not involve illegal acts.
When faced with a situation where a supervisor asks you to perform a lawful but immoral act, it is important to approach it carefully and ethically. Here are steps you can take to navigate such a situation:
1. Recognize your values and ethical standards: Begin by reflecting on your personal values and ethical principles. Consider what you believe is right and wrong, and identify how this request conflicts with your moral compass.
2. Analyze the situation: Carefully consider the nature of the task and its potential consequences. Assess the impact it may have on various stakeholders, including yourself, colleagues, and the wider community. Evaluate whether the request aligns with ethical standards and legal obligations.
3. Seek clarification: If the request seems unclear or if you have any doubts, seek further clarification from your supervisor. Politely and respectfully ask for additional information or context to better understand the reasoning behind their request.
4. Consult an ethical framework: Consider applying an ethical framework or approach to help guide your decision-making process. Some common frameworks include consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Each has its own principles and concepts that can assist in analyzing the situation.
5. Explore alternative actions: Identify alternative courses of action that align with your ethical values. Think about possible compromises or strategies that could satisfy your supervisor's concerns while also mitigating the moral implications.
6. Discuss with trusted colleagues or mentors: Seek advice and guidance from colleagues or mentors whom you trust and respect. Share your concerns and seek their perspectives on the situation. They may offer valuable insights and help you gain a different perspective.
7. Engage in open communication: Initiate an open and honest conversation with your supervisor. Express your concerns, making sure to articulate why you find the action immoral. Present your alternative suggestions or compromises in a respectful manner, emphasizing how they can achieve the desired outcome while upholding ethical standards.
8. Document the situation: Keep a record of conversations, email exchanges, and any other relevant evidence. Having documentation can be valuable in later stages if the situation escalates or if you need to report the incident to higher authorities or human resources.
9. Seek higher-level guidance: If the discussion with your supervisor fails to resolve the issue, consider escalating it to a higher level of management or a designated ethics hotline within your organization. Follow your company's policies and procedures for addressing ethical concerns or whistleblowing.
10. Decide on a course of action: Based on the insights gained, make a decision on how to proceed. Consider the impact on your professional reputation, career progression, and personal well-being. It may be necessary to refuse to perform the task, seek a transfer, or consider alternative employment options if the situation cannot be resolved ethically.
Remember, navigating such situations requires courage and a commitment to ethical conduct. While it may be challenging, it is crucial to uphold your values and integrity, even in the face of difficult choices.