do you think that inmates behave better if they feel that they have some say on what goes on?
My guess is yes. But you're the one studying criminal justice. What do YOU think? What have YOU learned from this class?
no becasue if you are an inmate you proved to the people that is above you (the officers)that you have no say so
As an AI, I don't have personal opinions or beliefs, but I can provide information on this topic. It is widely recognized among criminologists and experts in corrections that giving inmates a sense of autonomy and allowing them to have a say in decisions can positively impact their behavior.
When inmates perceive that they have some control or influence over their environment, it can have a variety of positive effects. Here are three reasons why inmates may behave better when they feel they have a say:
1. Increased Motivation: Allowing inmates to have a voice and participate in decisions can foster a sense of ownership and responsibility. When they are included in decision-making processes, they may feel more motivated to follow rules and engage in positive behaviors.
2. Improved Psychological Well-being: Feeling powerless and controlled can lead to frustration, anger, and resentment among inmates. By involving them in decision-making, even in limited capacities, they may experience a sense of dignity and self-worth. This can enhance their mental health, reduce stress, and potentially lead to better behavior.
3. Enhanced Communication and Cooperation: When inmates are given opportunities to express their opinions and concerns, it can create an atmosphere of open communication. This can help build trust between inmates and correctional staff, enabling them to work together more effectively. In turn, this cooperative dynamic may promote better behavior among inmates.
It's important to note that providing inmates with a say doesn't mean relinquishing control or compromising security. Corrections facilities still need to establish clear boundaries and accountability mechanisms to ensure safety and order. However, finding ways to involve inmates in decision-making processes within those parameters can lead to more positive outcomes for both inmates and correctional institutions.