I think that paragraph 3 is more effective than paragraph 1 because it is structured in a better manner and has better rhythm than paragraph1. It also has better structures sentences than paragraph 1. For example in paragraph 1 sentences like, ‘My Aunt Martha went to a lawyer to get a will, I did my will online. My dad died in 1988. He didn’t have a will’ are not correctly written. Also, the sentence variety is better in paragraph 3. The first paragraph has lot of short and unlinked sentences and at many times, it is not making sense to have so many sentences. The third paragraph has better sentence structure and rhythm. It is more interesting to read the third paragraph, then the first one. There is no sentence variety in the first paragraph and all the sentences start in the same manner and all of them are short ones. But, in the third paragraph also there are ample numbers of issues but better sentence structure is what makes it a better paragraph. The sentences are far too long and could have a better rhythm. Even the word choice could have been better in paragraph one and it seems to be very personal and unplanned.

Question

I think that paragraph 3 is more effective than paragraph 1 because it is structured in a better manner and has better rhythm than paragraph1. It also has better structures sentences than paragraph 1. For example in paragraph 1 sentences like, ‘My Aunt Martha went to a lawyer to get a will, I did my will online. My dad died in 1988. He didn’t have a will’ are not correctly written. Also, the sentence variety is better in paragraph 3. The first paragraph has lot of short and unlinked sentences and at many times, it is not making sense to have so many sentences. The third paragraph has better sentence structure and rhythm. It is more interesting to read the third paragraph, then the first one. There is no sentence variety in the first paragraph and all the sentences start in the same manner and all of them are short ones. But, in the third paragraph also there are ample numbers of issues but better sentence structure is what makes it a better paragraph. The sentences are far too long and could have a better rhythm. Even the word choice could have been better in paragraph one and it seems to be very personal and unplanned.

I feel this is the topic sentence => I think that paragraph 3 is more effective than paragraph 1 because it is structured in a better manner and has better rhythm than paragraph1. <= do you feel this is a good topic sentence??

Answer 1

Yes, the sentence "I think that paragraph 3 is more effective than paragraph 1 because it is structured in a better manner and has better rhythm than paragraph 1" can be considered a topic sentence. A topic sentence typically introduces the main idea or argument of a paragraph, and in this case, it is stating the opinion that paragraph 3 is more effective than paragraph 1 based on its structure and rhythm.

To determine if this is a good topic sentence, we can analyze it based on a few criteria:

1. Clear focus: The topic sentence clearly states the main idea and focuses on comparing the structure and rhythm of paragraph 3 and paragraph 1.

2. Specificity: The topic sentence specifically mentions the reasons why paragraph 3 is considered more effective, namely its better structure and rhythm compared to paragraph 1.

3. Coherence: The topic sentence sets up the logical flow of the paragraph, as the subsequent sentences will likely provide examples and further explanations to support the stated opinion.

Considering these criteria, the given topic sentence appears to be appropriate as it clearly introduces the main idea and provides a clear focus for the paragraph.

agreed