Write an essay comparing Baldwin's account of the Titanic with Rosenthal's account of his visit to Auschwitz. In your paragraph, explain how the tone and purpose of each essay is different. Support your argument with at least one example from each essay.

Hello I really can't understand this question I've read both stories lots of times but I still don't get it I really need some help to understand this question Thanks....

Randell

Make notes for yourself -- one page of notes for one author and work; another page for the other.

What is the tone of this essay? What are the emotions the author feels about his topic?
http://www.cliffsnotes.com/Section/What-is-tone-exactly-and-how-do-you-find-it-in-stories-.id-305408,articleId-8021.html

What is each author's purpose in writing his essay? Who are his intended readers?
(Read several of these.)
http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=purpose+audience+in+writing

Oh thank you so much for helping me ! :D

Hello Randell! I'm here to help you understand the question and guide you through writing an essay comparing Baldwin's account of the Titanic with Rosenthal's account of his visit to Auschwitz. Understanding the tone and purpose of each essay is crucial for comparing them effectively. Let's break it down step by step.

1. Read the essays thoroughly: Start by reading both Baldwin's account of the Titanic and Rosenthal's account of his visit to Auschwitz. Take notes on important aspects of each essay, such as the tone, purpose, and any relevant examples that illustrate these elements.

2. Analyze the tone of each essay: Tone refers to the writer's attitude towards the subject matter. Identify the overall tone of Baldwin's essay and contrast it with Rosenthal's tone in his Auschwitz account. Consider the emotions conveyed, the language used, and any other stylistic choices the authors make.

For example, Baldwin's tone in his Titanic account is deeply reflective and mournful. He expresses a sense of tragedy and loss, exploring themes of mortality and the impermanence of human existence. In contrast, Rosenthal's tone in his Auschwitz account may carry elements of despair and horror, as he recounts his firsthand experience in the concentration camp.

3. Identify the purpose of each essay: Purpose refers to the reason behind the writing. Baldwin and Rosenthal may have different intentions in writing their respective essays. Consider what they aim to achieve through their accounts and how these objectives differ.

For instance, the purpose of Baldwin's essay on the Titanic might be to highlight the hubris of humans and the consequences of overconfidence in technological progress. He seeks to provoke introspection and reflection on the fragility of human life. On the other hand, Rosenthal's purpose in his Auschwitz account may be to bear witness to the atrocities and educate readers about the horrors of the Holocaust, aiming to prevent such acts from happening again.

4. Draw on specific examples: To support your argument, choose at least one example or quote from each essay that reflects the tone and purpose you have identified. These examples should showcase the differences between the two essays.

For example, in Baldwin's essay, he may describe the haunting image of the ship sinking and the screams that filled the air, evoking a somber atmosphere. This example highlights the reflective and mournful tone he adopts. In Rosenthal's account, he might vividly describe the conditions of the camp, including the sights, sounds, and inhumane treatment, creating a sense of horror and emphasizing his purpose of bearing witness.

By analyzing the tone and purpose of each essay and providing specific examples, you will be able to contrast the differences between Baldwin's account of the Titanic and Rosenthal's account of Auschwitz effectively. Remember to structure your essay with clear paragraphs, introduction, and conclusion, and support your arguments with evidence from the texts. Good luck with your essay!