Crt 205 Vacuum Sales Digital Story Text
Axia College Material
Text of the Vacuum Sales Digital Story
This text provides the script of the Vacuum Sales digital story. Use this text as an alternative or supplement to viewing the digital story itself.
Script
“The other day when I got home from work I heard a knock at our front door. It was a salesperson selling vacuum cleaners.
He had a vacuum with him that he claimed was the latest in vacuum cleaning technology. He asked me to come into the living room and then he guy dumped a huge pile of dirt on my white carpet! I was about to tell him to get lost when he vacuumed it all up and sure enough it was completely gone. I couldn’t believe it, the carpet looked brand new!
Then he said…
“Anyone who wants a comfortable, clean home needs this amazing vacuum cleaner.
Is this Essay helpful? Join OPPapers to read more and access more than 200,000 just like it!
get better grades
You certainly look like someone who likes having a really clean home. So, you definitely need this vacuum cleaner!”
I told the salesperson he made a convincing argument but that I needed some time to think about it. So he agreed to come back in a few hours for my answer.
A few minutes later, my wife came home from work and I told her what happened.
She said…
“Honey, our carpets are clean and we already have a working vacuum cleaner. We don’t need a new one!”
After she said that, the salesperson came back to the house and I had to tell him that though I do like our floors to be clean, based on what my wife said I’m not so sure we need a new vacuum cleaner. He didn’t look too pleased about my decision but left his business card anyway. I closed the door, and I heard my wife yell from the kitchen, “That reminds me honey, it’s your turn to vacuum the house!”
Discussion Question 1: Post your response to the DQ1 thread in the Main Forum by Day 2
View the Vacuum Sales digital story located on the Materials tab of your student Web site for Week Six. Of the two Arguments provided in the digital story, which is valid and which is sound? What do you feel is more important in an argument, to be valid or sound? Explain your answer please.
How would you like us to help you with this assignment?
View the Vacuum Sales digital story located on the Materials tab of your student Web site for Week Six. Of the two Arguments provided in the digital story, which is valid and which is sound? What do you feel is more important in an argument, to be valid or sound? Explain your answer please.
To determine which argument in the Vacuum Sales digital story is valid and which is sound, you should view the digital story located on the Materials tab of your student Web site for Week Six. However, based on the information provided in the text, we can analyze the arguments as follows:
Argument 1: The salesperson claims that the vacuum cleaner is the latest in vacuum cleaning technology and demonstrates its effectiveness by vacuuming up a pile of dirt from the white carpet, making it completely clean.
Argument 2: The wife argues that they already have a working vacuum cleaner and do not need a new one.
From this information, we can infer that Argument 1 is valid because it presents evidence (vacuuming up the dirt) to support the claim (the vacuum cleaner is effective). On the other hand, Argument 2 can be considered sound because it is logical and reasonable to conclude that if they already have a working vacuum cleaner, they do not need a new one.
Now, let's discuss the importance of validity and soundness in an argument. In logic, an argument is valid if the conclusion follows logically from the premises. This means that if the premises are true, the conclusion must also be true. On the other hand, an argument is sound if it is valid and its premises are true.
In terms of importance, validity is a crucial aspect of an argument because it ensures that the conclusion logically follows from the premises. A valid argument can be considered strong and persuasive. However, soundness is equally important because it not only requires validity but also demands that the premises are true. A sound argument is not only logically correct but also based on true information or evidence.
In conclusion, both validity and soundness are important in an argument. Validity ensures logical coherence, while soundness adds credibility and reliability by requiring the premises to be true. To have a strong and convincing argument, it is essential to strive for both validity and soundness.