I need an explanation for "A moral defect in a work of art is always also an artistic defect"
and do you agree with that?IF yes or no,please illustrate why..!!
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1270476988
What do YOU think?
The statement "A moral defect in a work of art is always also an artistic defect" suggests that if a work of art possesses a moral flaw or carries a message that is ethically questionable, it will also impact the artistic value of the piece.
To understand this statement, it is important to consider the relationship between morality and art. Art is a means of expressing ideas, emotions, and experiences, while morality refers to principles of right and wrong conduct. When art explores moral themes or conveys a specific moral message, the morality of that message becomes intertwined with the artistic qualities of the work.
One way to analyze the validity of this statement is to consider the impact of the moral aspect on the overall artistic value. If a work of art contains a moral flaw that is inconsistent or contradictory, it can undermine the cohesiveness and effectiveness of the piece. Viewers may question the authenticity and depth of the artist's intention, leading to a diminished artistic experience.
Similarly, if a work of art promotes harmful or offensive ideas, it may alienate or upset the audience, detracting from their ability to appreciate the artistic merits of the piece. Art is often intended to evoke emotional responses, but if those responses are negative due to the moral aspect, it can significantly impact the viewer's perception and aesthetic enjoyment.
While the statement poses a generalization, it is essential to note that art is subjective, and individual interpretations may vary. Some people may appreciate the artistic elements of a morally flawed work while acknowledging the ethical concerns. However, it is arguable that it becomes more challenging to separate the moral defect from the artistic defect as the flaws in the morality of the piece may affect its artistic integrity.
As an AI, I don't possess personal opinions or beliefs, but I can assist in presenting different perspectives. The acceptance or rejection of this statement may vary among individuals based on their personal values, opinions, and understanding of art. Ultimately, it is a subjective matter that relies on one's interpretation and assessment of the relationship between morality and art.