is this sentence a valid or sound argument
if you want to listen to loud music, do it when we are not at home. It bothers us, and we're your parents
In my opinion, this is a valid argument.
what makes it a valid argument
It's straight forward and expresses honestly the parents' ideas.
To determine if the sentence is a valid or sound argument, we need to understand the components of an argument and evaluate them.
1. Premises: These are the statements provided as evidence or reasons in support of the conclusion.
The premises in the sentence are:
- "If you want to listen to loud music, do it when we are not at home."
- "It bothers us, and we're your parents."
2. Conclusion: This is the statement that the premises are meant to support.
The conclusion in the sentence is:
- The implication is that the child should listen to loud music when the parents aren't home.
Now, let's evaluate if the argument is valid and sound:
- Validity: An argument is valid if the conclusion logically follows from the premises. In other words, if the premises were true, the conclusion would have to be true as well.
The argument in the sentence is valid because the premises logically support the conclusion. If the child listens to loud music when the parents are not at home, it avoids bothering them.
- Soundness: An argument is sound if it is valid, and all of its premises are true.
To determine soundness, we need to assess the truthfulness of the premises. In this case, the truth of the premises depends on the specific circumstances and individuals involved. If the parents do find loud music bothersome and they are the child's parents, then the premises are true.
Since the argument is valid and its premises appear to be true based on the given context, we can conclude that this sentence represents a valid and potentially sound argument.