I would just like to get a view of anyone's opinion on Shakespeare Hamlet the book vs the movie starring Mel Gibson and Glen Close...which scenes in the movie do you feel had a greater impact than it did in the book?
I'm sure your teacher wants YOUR opinion. S/he does NOT want anyone else's opinion.
There are 79 different opinions of that movie at
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0099726/
I was not aware of the movie; the Olivier version is hard to improve upon. Make sure you view the movie yourself and do not plagiarize the opinions of others.
The movie version with Mel Gibson and Glenn Close was released in 1990. There's also a version with Kenneth Branagh in it (1995, I think), and the Laurence Olivier version from the 1940s. All three of these stay fairly close to the text of the play.
Now you just need to decide which scenes you will use and how you will compare/contrast them with the text -- and remember that the text relies on your imagination. I hope you read the play before you saw the movie; otherwise, this assignment will be impossible for you.
I have only seen the Olivier version - yes, in the 1940s! I know he intentionally did it in black and white, and NOT color. If the news ones are in color, you might consider Olivier's philosophy on the movie.
Sra
To compare the impact of scenes in the book "Hamlet" by William Shakespeare with the Mel Gibson and Glenn Close movie adaptation, it is essential to read the book and watch the movie. Taking note of key scenes in both mediums will help in forming an opinion. Here's how you can do it:
1. Read the book: Start by obtaining a copy of Shakespeare's "Hamlet." You can purchase a physical book, borrow one from a library, or find an online version. As you read, take note of the scenes that stand out or leave a strong impression on you. Reflect on the emotions, themes, and character development showcased in these scenes.
2. Watch the movie: Find the movie adaptation of "Hamlet" starring Mel Gibson and Glenn Close. It should be available on various streaming platforms or through DVD rentals. While watching, pay close attention to the interpretation of the scenes you previously identified from the book. Observe the visuals, performances, and any changes or additions made to the original material.
3. Compare the impact: After experiencing both the book and the movie, reflect on which scenes you believe had a greater impact in the film adaptation. Consider factors such as the actors' performances, cinematography, soundtrack, and any creative choices made by the director. Analyze how these elements enhance or detract from the emotional depth and resonance of the scenes.
It is important to note that responses to this question will vary based on personal preferences, interpretations, and individual experiences of the book and the movie. While some scenes may have a greater impact in the movie due to visual storytelling and performance nuances, others might have a more powerful effect in the book through Shakespeare's poetic language and the reader's imagination.
Ultimately, engaging with both the book and the movie will allow you to form your own opinion and contribute to a more comprehensive discussion on the topic.