After the War of 1812, there emerged a group of Republicans who urged the nation to consider "national" issues rather than "local" or "sectional" matters. So persistent were they that many of their party contended that they were abandoning the basic principles laid down by Jefferson. Were they? Could this new group be called "Jeffersonian," or did it represent something else? Examine the things the nationalists proposed for the nation, compare their plans with those of Jefferson and Hamilton. To which set of plans does the nationalists' program seem more closely allied? What does this tell you about the nature of political parties and political ideas at this time? Also, how does the emergence of the nationalists relate to the decline of the Federalists?
Please note that we don't do students' homework for them. Be sure to go back into your textbook or use a good search engine. http://hanlib.sou.edu/searchtools/
Once YOU have come up with attempted answers to YOUR questions, please re-post and let us know what you think. Then someone here will be happy to comment on your thinking.
To answer this question, let's break it down into several parts:
1. Were the Republicans who urged the nation to consider "national" issues abandoning the principles laid down by Jefferson?
To determine this, we need to understand Jefferson's principles. Thomas Jefferson was a Democratic-Republican and believed in limited government, states' rights, agrarianism, and strict interpretation of the Constitution. The group of Republicans emerging after the War of 1812, often referred to as nationalists or the "American System" proponents, did advocate for policies that expanded the role of the federal government and prioritized national economic growth. While this did deviate from some of Jefferson's principles, it is important to note that political ideologies and party platforms can evolve over time.
2. Could this new group be called "Jeffersonian," or did it represent something else?
The nationalists represented a departure from traditional Jeffersonian Republicanism. They embraced policies aimed at promoting American manufacturing, infrastructure development, and protective tariffs to safeguard domestic industries. This group, led by figures like Henry Clay and John C. Calhoun, can be seen as promoting a more nationalist and interventionist approach to governance.
3. How does the nationalists' program compare with the plans of Jefferson and Hamilton?
Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton, a Federalist, had opposing views on several key issues. Hamilton advocated for a strong central government, industrialization, a national bank, and a loose interpretation of the Constitution. On the other hand, Jefferson favored a limited federal government, an agrarian society, strict construction of the Constitution, and was skeptical of a national bank. The nationalists' program aligns more closely with Hamilton's economic policies, such as supporting manufacturing, infrastructure projects, and the establishment of a national bank.
4. What does this tell you about the nature of political parties and political ideas at this time?
The emergence of the nationalists illustrates that political parties and ideas are not static; they evolve and adapt to changing circumstances. The Republicans who embraced nationalist policies were responding to the challenges and opportunities presented by industrialization, westward expansion, and the aftermath of the War of 1812. This suggests that political parties are not simply monolithic entities with fixed ideologies, but rather, they are shaped by the prevailing political and economic climate.
5. How does the emergence of the nationalists relate to the decline of the Federalists?
The decline of the Federalist Party can be attributed to multiple factors, including the unpopularity of the War of 1812, the perceived elitism of the party, and the emergence of new political alignments. As the Federalists weakened, the Republicans began to splinter into factions, with some veering towards nationalist policies. This further contributed to the decline of the Federalists and the reshaping of American politics into a two-party system dominated by the Democratic-Republicans and the emerging nationalist wing.
In summary, the Republicans who advocated for nationalist policies after the War of 1812 deviated from Jeffersonian principles, aligning more closely with Hamiltonian economic policies. Their emergence represented the evolution of political parties and ideas in response to changing circumstances, leading to the decline of the Federalists and the reshaping of the Republican Party.