Would you have rather preferred to stay in France and live in a feudal-style farm or move to Canada and live as a habitant. Make a list of pros and cons for each option. Consider criteria such as familiarity of surroundings, physical labour, and taxes.
I would have preferred to move to Canada and live as a habitant. I wouldn't want to stay in france for the rest of my life paying taxes and fees. I wouldn't have even been able to make a modest amount of money living there. By moving to Canada I could cultivate my land in exchange for providing fees and services to the seigneur. I could also have the oppurtunity to work in fur trade. In Canada I would still have to pay my taxes and dues to the seigneur but not as much as I would have to In France. I could build a house in Canada and farm the land. Life would be a lot easier for me in Canada.
Please add any more information, thanks
Good job, Sara!
Ms. Sue where would you have rather prefered to live, in France or Canada?
I'd have preferred to live in Canada. However, if I had family and friends in France, it would be very difficult to leave them.
Why don't you ask your parents or grandparents why any of your ancestors moved to Canada from a foreign country.
Certainly! Here is a more detailed list of pros and cons for each option:
France (Feudal-style farm):
Pros:
1. Familiar surroundings: If you are already living in France, staying in the country would mean living in a familiar environment, with a cultural and linguistic context you are accustomed to.
2. Community support: Feudal-style farms often have a close-knit community of fellow farmers and workers, providing a sense of belonging and support.
3. Potential stability: Feudal systems typically provide a defined role for individuals within society, offering a certain level of stability and predictability in daily life.
Cons:
1. Taxes and fees: France's feudal system often imposed heavy taxes and fees on its citizens, which could significantly impact your income and financial well-being.
2. Limited social mobility: The hierarchical structure of feudalism could curtail social mobility, making it difficult to pursue other opportunities or improve your living conditions.
3. Limited economic prospects: Feudal-style farms may not provide ample opportunities for economic growth or advancement.
Canada (Habitant):
Pros:
1. Economic opportunities: Moving to Canada as a habitant could offer greater economic prospects, such as participating in fur trade or cultivating your own land for a modest income.
2. Lower taxes: Compared to France, Canada may have lower tax burdens and fees, resulting in a more favorable financial situation.
3. Freedom and independence: Becoming a habitant in Canada would allow you to build your own house, farm your land, and have more control over your own destiny.
Cons:
1. Unfamiliar surroundings: Moving to Canada would mean adapting to a new country, culture, and potentially a different language, which might involve some initial challenges.
2. Physical labor: Both feudal-style farming in France and being a habitant in Canada would require physical labor; however, the extent and nature of the work may vary.
3. Uncertain success: While Canada may offer more economic opportunities, success as a habitant would heavily rely on factors such as weather conditions, market demand, and individual entrepreneurship.
It's important to note that these lists may not encompass all the factors that should be considered when making a decision. Personal preferences, individual circumstances, and specific aspirations should also be taken into account.