science (chem& statistics)

For a wine titration my results obtained were...
0.6402%, 0.5814%,& 0.6006%
the I calculated was 0.04936
according to my text sometimes the # is expressed in ppt or 100%
first which would be correct if asked to submit a RSD for the results of a lab like this and 2nd what would be the significance of this # be?
Even though I know from the text that it says that it measures the preciseness of the values, I don't exactly know what the significance of say my RSD for my result (0.04936) means when describing the preciseness of my results as that isn't described in the book.


The standard deviation is 0.02998. The mean is 0.6074. The relative standard deviation is 0.02998/0.6074 = 0.04936 as you calculated above. That is 4.936% (parts per hundred) or 49.36 parts per thousand. So any of the three [0.04936 (which is parts per one), 4.936% OR 49.36 ppt] would be correct if how it is to be expressed is not listed. My opinion is that the precision you report is not that good. You can judge how good by looking at the example in your text where standard deviation and relative standard deviation are discussed. In my 6th edition, five numbers are reported as 0.752, 0.756, 0.752, 0.751, 0.760. The s.d. is 0.00377 and the mean is 0.7542. Thus RSD is 0.00377/0.7542 = 0.00500 which is 0.5% or 5 ppt (which I consider rather good (but not GREAT) precision and the precison you quote, on the same scale is about 10 times poorer. Note in the five numbers that the variation, for the most part, is in the 3rd place while your deviations are in the second place.


AWW...I have to make a lab report on this..great..(I think it was the color problem again b/c I couldn't decide which brown was "brown" for the wine endpoint)..but what value of a RSD would be good? since you said the other one from the bk is good but not great..is there a # that I should be aiming for when doing the calculations?


2 ppt is really quite good. However, your lab may be a "finish the experiment with acceptable results--whatever acceptable is" or graded in relative error from the accepted value.

It's not really that much of my grade b/c my prof said that it was only worth 5 points so I guess I'll have to type error as a factor in the results.
But since I have to write a abstract for my paper I was wondering if it was better to write it at the beginning or the end of the lab report.

If I was to eliminate 1 value as an outlier would I go and include that in calculations of the RSD? I would assume not since It would affect the RSD
And how would I decide on a confidence level for the Q test? How would I know if it was 90/95/or 99% conficence? It's not explained how would you choose
this.

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 123

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Chemistry Lab

    Last week, I did titration of Zn with EDTA experiment. I used calmigte as the indictor. The endpoint of this titration is supposed to be blue. The color change go from wine-red to violet to Blue. I did a mistake by stopping the

    asked by Beckhamano on November 10, 2008
  2. Chemistry Lab

    Last week, I did titration of Zn with EDTA experiment. I used calmigte as the indictor. The endpoint of this titration is supposed to be blue. The color change go from wine-red to violet to Blue. I did a mistake by stopping the

    asked by Beckhamano on November 10, 2008
  3. chemistry

    We did an experiment on Quantitative Analysis of Soda ash by Double-Indicator Titration. What is the cause of carbonate error and its effect on the calculated values obtained in standardizatin and sample analysis?

    asked by mitch on January 18, 2009
  4. science

    Bacteria are invisible to humans except under a microscope. Which evidence did Pasteur use to show that bacteria were the cause of soured wine? A. Heated wine did not sour B. Capped wine did not sour C. Filtered wine did not sour

    asked by PLZZ Help on January 26, 2015
  5. Chem 2

    Checking to see if I did this right? Titration of HN03 titrated with NaOH ending result is 1.38. Titration A, endpoint pH = 8 is pKa or pKb= 1.38x106=5.861 and Titration of NH03 titrated with KOH ending results 1.54. Titration B,

    asked by Debbie on March 21, 2012
  6. Algebra Word Problem Help

    Two wine merchants enter Paris, one of them with 64 casks of wine, the other with 20. Since they have not enough money to pay the custom duties, the first pays 5 casks of wine and 40 francs, and the second pays 2 casks of wine and

    asked by Breanna on August 10, 2009
  7. Chemistry

    At the beginning of a titration to standardize the NaOH solution, Student A adjusted very carefully the initial burette volume to 0.00 mL, but he did not notice an important air bubble in the tip of the burette. At the end of the

    asked by kobe on February 9, 2015
  8. Chemistry

    An air bubble is present in the stopcock at the start of the titration but is passed out during the titration. Would this error make your calculated molarity of zinc ions higher or lower than the true value? Thanks!

    asked by Joantense on February 28, 2012
  9. chemistry

    have my results from a simple titration experiment (sodium carbonate against hydrochloric acid) Average titre of 53.27 cm3 which i am happy with but how can i state that my results are accurate and how can i convince my lecturer

    asked by paul m on October 18, 2010
  10. math repost Please Help!

    Hello, In a class of 24 students, every student flips fairly two coins 40 times each and records the results. Assume that the class obtained the expected results when they conducted the experiment. a. Make a bar graph illustrating

    asked by joe on February 7, 2010

More Similar Questions