can old man and the sea and old man both be considered a tragedy/tragic hero since macbeth is driven by him ambition and santiago by his pride? is santiago a tragic hero since he is not of noble stature or great power?
A tragic hero doesn't need to be a noble or have great power. Check these sites for reasons for and against Santiago as a tragic hero.
http://www.lorenwebster.net/In_a_Dark_Time/2002/03/21/and-remains-standing-at-the-end/
http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/oldman/study.html
Both "The Old Man and the Sea" and "Old Man" can be considered as tragedies in certain ways. In order to determine if Santiago can be considered a tragic hero, we need to understand the characteristics of a tragic hero and analyze Santiago's character.
Traditionally, a tragic hero is a character who possesses noble qualities, often of high status or power, and faces a downfall or suffering caused by a tragic flaw. It is true that in the case of "Macbeth," his tragic flaw of ambition leads to his downfall. However, not all tragic heroes need to possess great power or be of noble stature.
In the case of Santiago, he may not have the high status or power typically associated with a tragic hero, but he does exhibit qualities that make him a candidate for a tragic hero. His pride, determination, and refusal to give up despite his suffering and struggles align with the characteristics of a tragic hero. Additionally, Santiago's pursuit of the marlin reflects his personal ambition and his desire to prove himself as a skilled fisherman, similar to how Macbeth's ambition drives him.
To determine if Santiago can be considered a tragic hero, it would be beneficial to consult the provided sources for different perspectives and arguments about Santiago's status as a tragic hero. The first link provides a discussion about Santiago's character and the tragic elements in the story. The second link offers a study guide that explores various aspects of the novel, including themes and characters, which can help in assessing Santiago's role as a tragic hero.
By examining these sources and considering the specific characteristics of a tragic hero, you can form a well-informed opinion on whether Santiago can be considered a tragic hero despite not having noble stature or great power.