the line "I stand up" in the poem "Miss Rosie" indicates that the speaker
a. is disgusted by Miss Rosie
b. feels responsible for Miss Rosie's destruction
c. respects what Miss Rosie has been through
d. thinks that she is better than Miss Rosie
i think it's D
so what do you guys think
now i'm thining on C too
We don't all interpret a poem the same way. Go with your own gut feeling.
It's C
because rosie is destroyed so now she feels better. 'i stand up through your destruction'
is this correct?
It could be -- but this site gives a different perspective.
http://litmed.med.nyu.edu/Annotation?action=view&annid=174
What do you think?
I would be happier with D if it said "thinks she will not fall away into drugs and helplessness as miss rosie did"
Amen.
still, do you have any opinions Ms.Sue?
:)
No, I don't have an opinion. I could throw a dart at both answers, and see where the dart landed. But I don't know what the poet intended in those last three lines.
The important thing is that you've thought through this poem and tried to interpret it. Your actual answer really isn't very important.
To determine the correct answer, let's go through the process of analyzing the poem "Miss Rosie" and finding supporting evidence for each option.
First, let's consider option A: "The line 'I stand up' indicates that the speaker is disgusted by Miss Rosie." To evaluate this option, we need to examine the context of the line and the events leading up to it.
Upon examining the poem, "Miss Rosie" by Lucille Clifton, we find that it is written in the first person and is a reflection on the life of a woman named Miss Rosie, who is described as old and worn down. The line "I stand up" appears towards the end of the poem and is a declaration made by the speaker after witnessing Miss Rosie dancing and celebrating her own life.
Option A suggests that the speaker is disgusted by Miss Rosie. However, there is no evidence in the poem to support this interpretation. The poem seems to focus more on Miss Rosie's resilience and the speaker's admiration for her.
Now let's consider option B: "The line 'I stand up' indicates that the speaker feels responsible for Miss Rosie's destruction." Again, there is no explicit evidence in the poem to support this interpretation. The poem does not address any feelings of responsibility on the part of the speaker towards Miss Rosie's circumstances.
Moving on to option C: "The line 'I stand up' indicates that the speaker respects what Miss Rosie has been through." This interpretation aligns more closely with the overall tone and content of the poem. The speaker acknowledges the challenges and struggles that Miss Rosie has endured throughout her life, yet still celebrates her resilience and ability to find joy in spite of it all. The act of standing up can be seen as a sign of respect and recognition for Miss Rosie's indomitable spirit.
Finally, let's evaluate option D: "The line 'I stand up' indicates that the speaker thinks that she is better than Miss Rosie." This interpretation does not align with the tone or message of the poem. The speaker's stance is not one of superiority, but rather one of admiration and acknowledgment.
Based on our analysis, it appears that option C, "The line 'I stand up' indicates that the speaker respects what Miss Rosie has been through," is the most accurate interpretation. The speaker's words convey a sense of reverence and admiration for Miss Rosie's resilience and ability to find joy despite her difficult circumstances.