economics

cattle rancher (A) owns a property next to an apple farm (B) cattle sometimes tent to roam into B's land and damage the trees. The rancher can choose the size of the herd. revenue form cattle is $6 per head. The following schedle lists A's marginal prodction cost(MPC) and the damage associated with each cattle is given by the MEC

Cattle# MPC$ MEC$
1 3 1
2 3 2
3 4 3
4 5 4
5 6 5
6 7 6

B can choose wether to farm or not.B's cost of prodction is $10 and revene is $12 when there is no cattle roaming loose. for each additional cattle B's revene is reduced by the margianl external cost MEC listed above.

1 what is the market outcome if there is no liablilty ( A does nopt pay for the damages caused)

2 what is the market outcome if A is liable for damages caused.

3 what is the efficient outcome

4 suppose that it is possible to bild a fence to enclose the ranch for the cost of $9. what is the efficient otcome in this case.

5 Suppose B can protect the trees by building a fence for the cost of $1 what is the efficient outcome.

if any one can please please help me that will be greatly appreciated


Assume both the farmer and rancher are both morally bankrupt and have no concern for the welfare of the other.

in 1) The rancher will produce where MC=MR. From the table, 5 cows. (or 4; the rancher is indifferent between the two levels).
Now the hard part. What does the farmer do. His total revenue is 12. His total cost given the rancher's 5 cows is 10+5=15. Now then, ask the question, can the farmer pay the rancher enough to cut back his herd size and yet still turn a production profit? The rancher would need to paid $9 to stop production completely. (Nadia, how did i arrive at this figure). Since the maximum profit for the farmer is $2, he will not produce at all.

2) Calculate production for the rancher when marginal costs include damages.

3) Both solutions are efficient. (Actually, because of lumpy-ness in the data, total combined profits under 1 are higher than under 2).

4) Who pays for the fence? Not the farmer because his total profit sans cattle is only $2. Not the rancher as his maximum profit from production is $9.

5) See reasoning in 4.


I want to revise my answer to question #3. Only the first solution is efficient. When the rancher must compensate for all of his damages is he will raise 2 cows and compensate the farmer $3. However, $3 exceeds the farmer's maximum profit. Thus, the rancher over-compensates.

Now then, if the rancher need only compensate for the economic loss to the farmer, he would limit his payment at $2. This becomes a fixed cost, and the rancher would raise 5 cows. This too is an efficient solution.

  1. 👍
  2. 👎
  3. 👁

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Social Studis

    Which pull factor would most likely encourage an immigrant who wanted to raise and sell cattle in the United States

  2. Calculus

    a rancher has 1200 fet of fencing to enclose two adjacent cattle pens. What dimensions should be used so that the enclosed area is maximized?

  3. Social studies please help :) thank u so much!

    what is one of the values revealed through the indian epics A: the equality of men and women B: the importance of duty over personal desires C: the superiority of the nobility D: the knowledge gained through war and conquest How

  4. Calculus

    A rancher wants to construct two identical rectangular corrals using 300 ft of fencing. The rancher decides to build them adjacent to each other, so they share fencing on one side. What dimensions should the rancher use to

  1. math

    1) A rancher wants to enclose two rectangular areas near a river, one for sheep and one for cattle. There is 240m of fencing available. Express the area of the enclosures as a function of its dimension.

  2. math

    1) A rancher wants to enclose two rectangular areas near a river, one for sheep and one for cattle. There is 240m of fencing available. Express the area of the enclosures as a function of its dimension. No there is no common side

  3. Calculus

    A cattle rancher wants to enclose a rectangular area and then divide it into six pens with fencing parallel to one side of the rectangle (see the figure below). There are 480 feet of fencing available to complete the job. What is

  4. Physics

    An airplane is dropping bales of hay to cattle stranded in a blizzard on the Great Plains. The pilot releases the bales at 120 m above the level ground when the plane is flying at 80.0 m/s 55.0 degrees above the horizontal. How

  1. Social Studies

    1. Why Did Cattle Owners have to buy private property on which to keep their cattle? A. They couldn't graze their cattle on Native American reservations. B. Cattle in open range herds got mixed together C. Farms and the railroads

  2. Maths

    A farmer sold 2/3 of his cattle.he gave 1/6 of the cattle to his son.what fraction of cows does he still have?

  3. science

    In cattle, red hair and white hair are codominant. Cattle with both white hair and red hair are what? please help! thanks!

  4. math

    1) A rancher wants to enclose two rectangular areas near a river, one for sheep and one for cattle. There is 240m of fencing available. Express the area of the enclosures as a function of its dimension. 2) A container company is

You can view more similar questions or ask a new question.