I need to provide arguments that mining is not horrible for the environment. I'm trying to look for stories that explain positive effects of mining, or how they help the environment (even if indirectly or in a small way). This is just very hard to find. Thank you.

Here are some sites that may be of use.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&ie=ISO-8859-1&q=Positive+aspects+of+mining&btnG=Google+Search

When looking for arguments that mining is not horrible for the environment, it's important to note that mining practices can have both positive and negative effects. While some mining activities can indeed cause significant harm to the environment, it is also possible to find examples of where mining efforts have had positive effects or beneficial environmental outcomes.

To find stories or examples highlighting these positive aspects of mining, you can follow these steps:

1. Start with academic research: Look for scholarly articles or publications that discuss case studies or research findings on the environmental impact of mining. Academic journals, such as the "International Journal of Mining, Reclamation and Environment," can provide insights into the diverse perspectives regarding mining's environmental effects.

2. Explore industry reports: Mining companies often release reports or publications showcasing their efforts towards mitigating environmental impacts. Seek out reports from reputable organizations, such as the International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM), which provide information on mining practices that prioritize environmental sustainability.

3. Government resources: Access information from government agencies responsible for regulating the mining industry. These agencies often publish reports and studies on mining practices, addressing environmental impacts and the measures implemented to minimize them. Websites of environmental protection agencies or mining regulatory bodies can be reliable sources of information.

4. Environmental organizations: Check for research or reports from reputable environmental organizations. These organizations frequently study the environmental impacts associated with mining and may highlight instances where mining has had positive environmental outcomes. Examples include reports from World Wildlife Fund (WWF), Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), or Sierra Club.

5. Case studies and success stories: Seek out case studies or examples where mining activities have positive environmental impacts. For instance, some abandoned mines have been repurposed for renewable energy projects or transformed into nature reserves, providing both ecological benefits and economic opportunities. Explore mining company websites or industry publications that may share success stories or initiatives focused on environmental stewardship.

Remember, finding specific stories or examples that showcase positive effects of mining on the environment can be challenging, as the negative impacts tend to receive more attention. However, by using a combination of the above-mentioned approaches, you may be able to find some instances where mining practices have had positive environmental outcomes.