Which is considered better therapeutic cloning or reproductive cloning? And what would be three main reasons why it is?
The word "better" implies a value judgment. What do YOU mean by better?
Do you understand these terms? Check out these sites -- and then tell us what YOU think.
http://www.religioustolerance.org/clo_ther.htm
http://www.pregnancy-info.net/StemCell/therapeutic_vs_reproductive.html
I have been researching the difference between these two all day. It's for my argumentive essay. After reading them I think that theraputic cloning is better. So would my thesis be something like Theraputic cloing is better then reproductive cloning because of religious beliefs, benefits, and I need one more reason please.
I'm afraid you haven't understood what you've researched.
Therapeutic cloning saves human lives.
Reproductive cloning produces new animals, plants or humans.
To me -- it's far more ethical to save human lives than to produce new people, animals or plants.
I understand. That's why i said before that my argumentive edge is going to argue why therapeutic cloning is better than reproductive. Isn't that what I was stating before in my thesis. I'm confused because we have to argue against two things. I need three reasons that I'm argue for why therapeutic cloning is better. I'm just not sure what some good reasons would be.
From the second website above:
"Therapeutic cloning is intended for medical use. The embryonic stem cells that this type of cloning produces can be used to create skin for burn victims, organs for transplant patients, or cells for those with spinal cord injuries. And because the cells come from the patient herself, there are no issues of cell rejection. Therapeutic cloning may also help those suffering from heart disease, Alzheimer's Disease, or Parkinson's Disease."
Therapeutic cloning sick people by creating
1. Skin for burn patients
2. Organs for transplant patients
3. Cells for those with spinal cord injuries
4. No possibility of rejections.
Determining whether therapeutic cloning or reproductive cloning is considered better is subjective and depends on the specific ethical, scientific, and societal contexts. However, I can provide you with an outline of three main reasons which are often discussed when considering the pros and cons of each:
1. Therapeutic Potential: One of the main advantages of therapeutic cloning is its potential for medical treatments. This method involves creating genetically identical cells, tissues, or organs that can be used for transplantation or regenerative medicine. This can potentially aid in the treatment of various diseases and injuries, such as spinal cord damage, organ failure, and certain genetic disorders. Therapeutic cloning can offer personalized treatments, reduce the need for organ transplantation waiting lists, and minimize the risk of rejection.
2. Ethical Considerations: Therapeutic cloning is often considered ethically less controversial than reproductive cloning. Reproductive cloning involves creating a cloned human being – essentially duplicating an entire organism. This raises ethical concerns such as the potential for exploitation, identity issues, and devaluation of human life. Therapeutic cloning, on the other hand, does not aim to create a cloned individual but instead focuses on utilizing cloned cells for medical purposes, which many find more acceptable from an ethical standpoint.
3. Practical Feasibility: Currently, therapeutic cloning is considered more practically feasible than reproductive cloning. While reproductive cloning has been achieved in animals, it has proven to be more challenging and unstable in the context of human cloning. On the other hand, therapeutic cloning techniques have shown some promising results in animal models and medical research. This suggests that therapeutic cloning may be more realistic and attainable in the near future, making it a potentially more viable option for medical advancement.
It's important to note that these reasons are not exhaustive, and different experts may have different perspectives on the advantages and disadvantages of each cloning approach. It is always recommended to consult scientific literature, research papers, and experts in the field to obtain a comprehensive understanding of the topic based on the most up-to-date information.