The Senate In reality has no real job. Yes, the senates can disapprove or approve any piece of government legislation. If however the House of Common disagrees then they over rule the senates. If the prime minister loses the support of the House of Commons or the cabinet then he must resign. If the prime Minister losses the support from the senates it is like nothing happened. The prime Minster does not really care because that does not affect him in anyway shape or form. No, one really takes the senates seriously. The senate gives voice to provinces, why is it that many people do not support them? The senates have no real position; they are there just because.
Senates can give their opinion but in reality their opinion will not be taken into consideration. For example in September 1990 everyone questioned the senate’s and ignored what they had to say about GST. The prime minister told the senate that they should not block the wishes of the House of Commons. This reinforces my opinion because the senates may try to be important but the government does not need the senates. I am not denying that the senates have not done a lot of investigation of political and social issues that Canada faces. However this job can be filled by Royal commissions or public inquiries. The government would be the way it is today with or with out the senates.
Should the Canadian senate be abolished? Is an important issue because this decides “whether the senators should be elected or appointed (and by whom), what regions groups or people they should represent, and what powers they should have.The senates can voice their opinions but their voice will not be heard. The House of Commons can overrule the senates meaning that senates are not really needed. The senates do not have public support. The prime Minster himself even accused the senates of blocking the wishes of the House of Commons. Meaning the prime Minster does not support the senates. I stand by my opinion the Canadian senate should be abolished
thanks in advance!!!
it would be senator's not senates
The Senate in Canada is indeed a controversial topic, and opinions vary on whether it should be abolished or reformed. It is important to note that this is a complex political issue, and different people have different perspectives on its purpose and effectiveness.
One way to explore this issue is to consider the various roles and functions of the Senate. The Senate has the power to approve or disapprove legislation proposed by the House of Commons, but if the House of Commons disagrees, it can overrule the Senate. This creates a dynamic where the House of Commons holds ultimate decision-making power.
One argument against the Senate is that it may not have direct influence over government decisions, as the Prime Minister and the House of Commons often hold more power. This perception may lead to the sentiment that the Senate has no real position or impact.
Moreover, there have been cases where the Senate's opinion or advice has not been taken into consideration by the government. For example, in September 1990, their input on GST (Goods and Services Tax) was questioned and ultimately ignored by the Prime Minister. This further supports the argument that the Senate's voice may not be given significant weight within the political landscape.
On the other hand, it is important to recognize that the Senate can provide a platform for different regions, groups, or people to voice their opinions and concerns. It has the potential to represent and protect the interests of various provinces. Some argue that this representation is valuable, as it ensures that different perspectives are taken into account during policymaking processes.
However, it is important to note that the Senate's role could potentially be fulfilled by other mechanisms, such as royal commissions or public inquiries. These alternatives may also investigate political and social issues faced by Canada, so some argue that the Senate's function may not be entirely essential.
Ultimately, the question of whether the Canadian Senate should be abolished or reformed is a matter of ongoing debate. It involves considering factors such as the Senate's ability to influence decision-making, its representation of different regions, and the potential alternatives to its functions. To form a well-informed opinion on this issue, further research and understanding of Canada's political system and its history with the Senate would be beneficial.