Why would two atoms form a covalent bond instead of an ionic bond?

Both atoms in a bond have similar electronegativity; thus, neither atom is willing to transfer their electrons. Instead, the atoms both share electrons to satisfy the octet rule.
Both atoms of the bond are metals, so neither can transfer electrons. Instead, the atoms share valence electrons in a free-moving sea of electrons.
One atom is a metal and the other a nonmetal, meaning there is a difference in electronegativity; thus, the atoms will transfer electrons. Each atom forms an ion to satisfy the octet rule.
The type of bond that is formed is based on the amount of energy that is supplied to excite the valence electrons. Thus, it would depend on the environment, not the atoms, involved.

Would it be D then?

The correct answer is: Both atoms in a bond have similar electronegativity; thus, neither atom is willing to transfer their electrons. Instead, the atoms both share electrons to satisfy the octet rule.

The correct answer is: One atom is a metal and the other a nonmetal, meaning there is a difference in electronegativity; thus, the atoms will transfer electrons. Each atom forms an ion to satisfy the octet rule.

To determine whether two atoms would form a covalent or ionic bond, we consider the electronegativity difference between the atoms. Electronegativity is the measure of an atom's ability to attract electrons in a chemical bond. If the electronegativity difference is small (less than 1.7), the atoms are likely to form a covalent bond.

In a covalent bond, atoms share their valence electrons to achieve a stable octet or duet configuration. This type of bond occurs when both atoms involved have similar electronegativity values. Since neither atom strongly attracts or donates electrons, they share them to fulfill the octet rule and form a stable compound.

On the other hand, when there is a significant electronegativity difference between atoms (greater than 1.7), an ionic bond is formed. Ionic bonds occur between a metal and nonmetal, where the metal atom donates electrons to the nonmetal atom. This electron transfer creates positively charged cations and negatively charged anions, which are attracted to each other due to their opposite charges.

In summary, if two atoms have a small electronegativity difference, they are more likely to form a covalent bond by sharing electrons. If there is a large electronegativity difference, they are more likely to form an ionic bond by transferring electrons to form ions.

almost to the point. All bonds are to somewhat ionic or covalent. You are correct it depends on energy. Electronegativity is the difference in energy of attraction...see this chart.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fdashboard.dublinschools.net%2Flessons%2F%3Fid%3Db14447368ffc26edfe0f1f8ebf045cd2%26v%3D1&psig=AOvVaw3rcpAZq7aQAr6SzHTxnRrd&ust=1573602982365000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAIQjRxqFwoTCMD175mu4-UCFQAAAAAdAAAAABAD