In speech 23, after nor tells carmody that they must send Eileen away carmody says

Question

In speech 23, after nor tells carmody that they must send Eileen away carmody says

Is it sen-din' Eileen way to a hospital you'd be? Exploding Then you'll not! You'll get notation out of your head...quick. It's all nonsense your'e stuff-in me with, and lies...

Which which aspect of his motivation does this dialogue most clearly revealed in the context of this scene?

A: His opposition to modern medicine
B: His desire to see Eileen parish
C: His desire to expose the doctor as a fraud******
D: his wish to avoid facing his daughter's illness
Am I RiGhT?

Answer 1

Disagree, I don't see a doctor mentioned.

Answer 2

I also Disagree. Maybe try reading or re-reading the story again. Maybe you will have a better understanding.

Answer 3

okay i changed my mind after re-reading is it D?

Answer 4

Without reading the whole story, it is hard to tell if it's D or A.

"Exploding Then"?

Answer 5

Based on the provided dialogue, the aspect of Carmody's motivation most clearly revealed in this scene is C: his desire to expose the doctor as a fraud. This can be inferred from Carmody's statement, "It's all nonsense you're stuffing me with, and lies." Here, Carmody expresses skepticism and disbelief towards the doctor's recommendation of sending Eileen to a hospital, implying that he believes the doctor is not being truthful or accurate in his diagnosis. Therefore, his motivation in this context appears to be exposing the doctor's alleged fraudulent actions.