What are the advantages and disadvantages of intrinsic & extrinsic aids?
https://www.google.com/search?q=intrinsic+and+extrinsic+aids&spell=1&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjnh8fJs-HfAhURWqwKHXFdAoEQBQgpKAA&biw=1024&bih=552
To understand the advantages and disadvantages of intrinsic and extrinsic aids, we first need to understand what these terms mean.
1. Intrinsic aids: These are sources of interpretation that are found within the legislation or legal document itself. They include headings, definitions, punctuation, and other grammatical features, as well as previous provisions or sections of the same document.
Advantages of intrinsic aids:
- Clarity and intention: Intrinsic aids can help provide a clearer understanding of the legislation's purpose and intention.
- Immediate availability: These aids are readily available within the document itself, making them easily accessible while interpreting the text.
- Direct connection: Intrinsic aids are directly connected to the legislation, ensuring a high level of relevance and accuracy.
Disadvantages of intrinsic aids:
- Limited scope: Intrinsic aids may not cover all potential ambiguities or provide sufficient guidance in complex situations, as they are confined to the text of the document.
- Subjectivity: The interpretation of intrinsic aids can be subjective, as different readers may have different perspectives on the meaning of certain provisions or grammar.
2. Extrinsic aids: These are sources of interpretation that are outside the legislation or legal document itself. They include historical context, legislative history, parliamentary debates, expert opinions, dictionaries, and other relevant sources.
Advantages of extrinsic aids:
- Comprehensive understanding: Extrinsic aids can provide a broader context and a deeper understanding of legislative provisions, especially when there is ambiguity or the text is unclear.
- Objective interpretation: Extrinsic aids often provide objective facts, such as legislative history, which can help in interpreting the original intent of the legislation.
Disadvantages of extrinsic aids:
- Reliability: The reliability and credibility of extrinsic aids can vary, making it important to choose trustworthy sources.
- Time-consuming: Utilizing extrinsic aids requires additional research and can be time-consuming, which may not be practical or feasible in some scenarios.
- Potential conflicts: Extrinsic aids can sometimes present conflicting information, leading to further confusion or uncertainty.
In conclusion, intrinsic aids offer immediate clarity but have limited scope and subjectivity, while extrinsic aids provide a comprehensive understanding but require more time and can be unreliable or conflicting. The choice between using intrinsic or extrinsic aids often depends on the specific context and the degree of clarity or ambiguity in the legislation being interpreted.