I have to write a 2 page essay on a court case in a movie.
I have a few questions because I don't understand what my professor wants when she says this:
-Evaluate the quality of information.
Does that mean I have to write about whether the details in the case are reliable?
-Identify and evaluate information presented.
So should I write details about the case in order?
-Recognize and defend against thinking error and making false assumptions.
Should I point out when the attorney was wrong and explain why?
-Agree or Disagree with the Judges Verdict and critically defend position as to why you agree or disagree.
She also says that I can't add my personal opinion I can only use the facts in the case
I think you've interpreted the instructions correctly.
When your professor asks you to "Evaluate the quality of information," she wants you to assess the reliability, accuracy, and credibility of the information presented in the court case. You should analyze whether the details provided in the movie are believable, consistent, and well-supported. This might involve considering factors like the sources of information, the expertise of the characters involved, and any inconsistencies or biases present.
Regarding "Identify and evaluate information presented," you don't necessarily need to present the details of the case in order. Instead, you should focus on analyzing the information presented and how it contributes to the overall case. You can discuss the key pieces of evidence, witness testimonies, or any other relevant information that plays a significant role in the case. Consider how well each piece of information supports the arguments made by the attorneys or influences the judge's decision.
When your professor asks you to "Recognize and defend against thinking error and making false assumptions," she wants you to identify instances where the lawyers or other characters in the movie court case demonstrate flawed reasoning or base their arguments on incorrect assumptions. You should point out where these errors occur and explain why they are problematic, unreliable, or irrelevant to the case. This shows your ability to critically evaluate the arguments and identify flaws in the thinking process.
Regarding the question of whether to "Agree or Disagree with the Judge's Verdict and critically defend your position using only the facts in the case," your professor wants you to analyze whether the judge's decision was fair, just, and in alignment with the evidence presented. However, you should base your agreement or disagreement solely on the facts and evidence in the case and not on personal opinions or biases. You should critically evaluate the judge's reasoning, the interpretation of the evidence, and any legal principles applied to reach the verdict.
Remember to support your evaluation and analysis with specific evidence or examples from the movie court case. By focusing on the provided facts and evidence in the case, you will ensure that your essay remains objective and analytical rather than based on personal opinions.