1. Why do you think sovereignty is a key component of a state?
2. What would the difference be between a nation and a state? For example, the Native American tribe of Cherokees are a nation, but not a state. Think about why.
I will be happy to check your thinking on this.
1. I think sovereignty is a key component of a state because the government makes the law.
2. A nation would be a group that is bound together as a single body. A state is a piece of land that is governed by sovereignty.
On the first, you need to specify that sovereignty allows the government to make and enforce laws, provide for the common welfare, and defense.
On the second, you plagarized without understanding. Go read the article, think, and put it in your own words.
Ok thx bob
1. Sovereignty is a key component of a state because it represents the highest authority within that territory. Sovereignty refers to the ability of a state to govern itself independently, without interference from external forces. It encompasses the state's power to make and enforce laws, control its borders, engage in international relations, and exercise exclusive authority over its territory and population.
To understand why sovereignty is a key component of a state, one can consider the fundamental principles of statehood. These principles include defined territory, a permanent population, a government, and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. Without sovereignty, a state would not be able to exercise these core functions, leading to a diminished ability to maintain order, protect rights, and make independent decisions for its citizens.
2. The difference between a nation and a state lies in their respective attributes and levels of political recognition. A nation refers to a community of people who share a common culture, language, history, and often have a sense of collective identity. This sense of shared identity can exist within a single state or span across multiple states. In the case of the Native American tribe of Cherokees, they can be considered a nation due to their shared cultural and historical characteristics.
On the other hand, a state is a political entity that exercises sovereign control over a defined territory and population. In order to be recognized as a state in the international system, certain criteria, like sovereignty, need to be met. While the Cherokees possess a distinct national identity, they do not have the same level of political recognition as a state. Historically, many indigenous tribes in the United States have been recognized as separate nations within the broader nation-state framework, without having full sovereign status.
The absence of statehood for the Cherokees can be attributed to historical and legal factors, including the colonization of their ancestral lands, forced assimilation policies, and existing legal frameworks that predominantly recognize the United States as the sovereign entity. However, it's important to note that the recognition of indigenous sovereignty continues to be a complex and evolving topic, with ongoing discussions and efforts towards acknowledging and affirming the rights and identities of indigenous nations.