What is the success criteria for the following genres,
- A newspaper report
- A balanced argument
- A biased argument
- An explanation
Thank you for using the Jiskha Homework Help Forum. This is indeed an interesting question. The rubric could depend upon just WHO is judging each genre. To my knowledge there are no ready statistics on this.
However, I would think, considering the term "literacy" one would consider the use of source material, the structure and development of the genre, the grammatical correctness. . .
To determine the success criteria for each genre, we can focus on the key elements and characteristics.
1. Newspaper Report:
- Accuracy and reliability of information: A successful newspaper report should be based on verified facts and sources.
- Clarity and objectivity: The report should present information clearly, without personal bias or opinion, and should avoid sensationalism.
- Organization and structure: The report should follow a logical flow, presenting the key details in a structured manner.
- Conciseness: A successful newspaper report should be concise, conveying the essential information without unnecessary details.
2. Balanced Argument:
- Presentation of multiple perspectives: A successful balanced argument should discuss various viewpoints on the topic to demonstrate fairness.
- Critical analysis: The argument should critically evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each perspective.
- Organization: The argument should be well-structured, with clear introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion.
- Support with evidence: Each perspective should be supported by reliable evidence, such as facts, statistics, or expert opinions.
3. Biased Argument:
- Assertion of a particular viewpoint: A biased argument aims to advocate for a specific position or opinion.
- Persuasiveness: A successful biased argument should employ strong rhetoric and persuasive techniques to convince the audience.
- Selective use of evidence: While evidence should still be present, a biased argument may omit or manipulate evidence to support the preferred viewpoint.
- Emotional appeal: Biased arguments often rely on emotions to sway the audience rather than solely relying on logic and reason.
4. Explanation:
- Clarity and coherence: A successful explanation should be clear and easy to understand, using language appropriate for the target audience.
- Adequate detail: The explanation should provide enough information to effectively convey the subject matter without overwhelming the reader.
- Logical flow: The explanation should be organized in a logical and sequential manner, presenting information in a step-by-step or cause-and-effect format.
- Use of examples or illustrations: Providing examples or illustrations can enhance the understanding and make the explanation more relatable.
Keep in mind that the success criteria may vary based on the specific requirements given by the instructor or the intended audience. It's important to refer to any guidelines or rubrics provided to ensure alignment with expectations.