hey, i have a question in which i need to know for and against points for a statement. this it the statement:
'Pilgrimage is a waste of money',
its hard for me to think of since i dont think it is a waste and i need points saying why some may think it is a waste of money. also please link this to islam and christianity, thanks x
Read lots. Let us know what you decide to write.
https://www.google.com/search?q=pilgrimages+in+christianity&oq=pilgrimages+in+christianity&aqs=chrome..69i57.8814j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
https://www.google.com/search?q=pilgrimage+in+islam&oq=pilgrimage+in+islam&aqs=chrome..69i57.5056j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
Thanks, for points against the statement i wrote :
-some may want to strengthen their faith, and be closer to god - it can be a powerful experience that changes the way people think of their religion and make them think about their religion and the way they act in a positive way
-some may believe if god has told you to do it (as it is a pillar in islam) and accept and believe something good will come out of it
to support the point i wrote :
-some may feel that their faith is strong enough and pilgrimage is unnecessary
-some people may have a weak faith and think pilgrimage is not beneficial
-some may believe there are other ways of strengthening faith like following the 10 commandments or the other 5 pillars which don't waste money but still make you closer to god - effect of pilgrimage may wear off but praying can have a lasting effect
When analyzing a statement and providing both for and against points, it's important to consider different perspectives. In the case of the statement "Pilgrimage is a waste of money," two main perspectives come to mind: those who believe in the value of pilgrimage and those who consider it a waste.
For Points (those in favor of the statement):
1. Cost: One argument against pilgrimage is the substantial amount of money it requires. Both Islam and Christianity have pilgrimage sites, such as Mecca for Muslims and Jerusalem for Christians. The expenses associated with travel, accommodation, food, and other logistics can add up quickly, making it a significant financial investment.
2. Limited Economic Impact: Detractors argue that the financial benefits of pilgrimage are often limited to the local economy around the pilgrimage sites. They contend that the broader economy fails to benefit substantially from the influx of pilgrims, which makes it seem like a poor allocation of financial resources.
Against Points (those against the statement):
1. Religious Significance: One of the main arguments in favor of pilgrimage is its religious importance. Both Islam and Christianity consider certain pilgrimage sites as sacred. Supporters of pilgrimage view it as an essential aspect of their religious practice, where they can connect with their faith, seek spiritual growth, and deepen their religious understanding.
2. Cultural and Historical Value: Pilgrimage sites often have significant cultural and historical importance. Many sites have been preserved for centuries, and visiting them allows pilgrims to engage with their religious heritage. Advocates argue that this experiential learning cannot be measured solely in monetary terms, as the value goes beyond financial considerations.
In addressing the specific link to Islam and Christianity:
- In Islam, Hajj (the pilgrimage to Mecca) is one of the Five Pillars of Islam, making it a religious obligation for financially and physically capable Muslims. Hajj is seen as a way to strengthen faith, purify the soul, and foster unity among Muslims.
- Within Christianity, different Christian denominations have various pilgrimage sites. Examples include the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem, which is significant to multiple Christian traditions. Pilgrims often visit these sites as an act of devotion, reflection, and personal spiritual renewal.
Remember, it's essential to consider various viewpoints when analyzing a statement like this.