Does the outcome go against the Potentiality Argument and/or the Future like our Argument against abortion?
A woman married seven years discovers she has multiple sclerosis. She stops using birth control pills because they aggravate the illness. In spite of reasonable precautions, she becomes pregnant. She has an abortion, explaining that "I cannot care for a child, and my husband cannot bear the burden alone." Both the woman and her husband are relieved and have no regrets
Since I haven't seen the argument against abortion, I have no idea. In any case, your teacher wants your analysis, not mine. What do YOU think?
make certain you know what the potentiality argument is. There are several widespread criticisms based on a false understanding of it. If in doubt, google.
The question you've asked seems to be about whether the outcome described contradicts the Potentiality Argument and/or the Future-like-ours Argument, which are arguments often used against abortion.
The Potentiality Argument is based on the idea that a fetus has the potential to develop into a person with moral worth, and that terminating the pregnancy is therefore morally wrong. The Future-like-ours Argument states that it is wrong to kill a being that has a future like ours, meaning they have the potential to have experiences, relationships, and a meaningful life.
In the given scenario, a woman with multiple sclerosis discovered she was pregnant and chose to have an abortion because she believed she could not care for the child and her husband couldn't bear the burden alone. The outcome described does not necessarily go against the Potentiality Argument or the Future-like-ours Argument.
To determine whether these arguments apply, one would need to consider the beliefs, values, and moral frameworks of the individuals involved. The woman and her husband might have made their decision based on factors such as their own well-being, their ability to provide for the child, or the potential negative impact on their relationship and quality of life. Their relief and lack of regret suggest that they believed the abortion was the best choice given their circumstances.
Ultimately, the outcome described does not provide a definitive answer regarding the moral implications of abortion according to the Potentiality Argument or the Future-like-ours Argument. These arguments are complex and subject to different interpretations and perspectives. To explore these issues further, it is important to engage in thoughtful discussions, consider various ethical theories, and weigh the moral considerations involved.