In the poems "Concrete Cat", "Haiku", and Limerick", the poets chose different forms to express their thoughts and feelings about the subject. Imagine that their poetic forms changed. How would each poem be different if its form were exchanged with another form? Write a paragraph about each poem would be different with a new form. Support you ideas with text evidence from the poem. PLS help I really need this
1. What is the defining characteristic of a concrete poem? What other characteristics must this type of poem have?
2. What is the definition of haiku poetry? What elements must each poem of that type have?
3. Ask yourself the same questions about limericks.
4. Find one of each type of poem, and use the three poems to help you explain the differences among them.
5. Then you'll be able to show and explain that none of them can be exchanged for any other without losing major elements that make them the type of poetry they are.
I hope this makes sense.
CROWD: OHHHHHH
Patiently waiting for someone to help a struggling student bc i have nO IDEA WHAT IM DOING
Of course! Let's analyze how the poems "Concrete Cat," "Haiku," and "Limerick" would be different if their forms were exchanged with new forms.
1. "Concrete Cat" by Dorthi Charles:
If the form of "Concrete Cat" were exchanged with a free verse form, the poem would be different. Currently, the poem's structure is shaped like a cat, reflecting the subject matter. By changing it to a free verse form, the poem would lose its visual representation, but the content would still convey the same ideas. For example, the phrase "his tumbling pride" would remain an engaging description of the cat's haughty behavior, regardless of the poem's form.
2. "Haiku" by Basho Matsuo:
The poem "Haiku" is already written in the traditional 5-7-5 syllable format. However, if its form were exchanged with a sonnet form, the poem's style and structure would change significantly. A sonnet typically has 14 lines with a specific rhyming scheme. In this case, the three-line nature of the haiku would have to be expanded, allowing for extended descriptions and emotions associated with the subject. For instance, the line "An old silent pond" would need further elaboration to fit within a sonnet's structure, while maintaining the underlying tranquility and simplicity portrayed in the original haiku.
3. "Limerick" by Edward Lear:
If "Limerick" were given a form exchange with a villanelle, the poem's playful tone would still be present, but the repetition and structure would differ. A villanelle consists of five tercets and a final quatrain, with repeated lines throughout. In this case, phrases like "They said, 'Come along, see the world!'" and "And seen as it's cheap, And the ship's very fleet" would be reworked to fulfill the repeating lines required by a villanelle structure. The resulting poem would have a more rhythmic and cyclical flow.
Remember, when discussing how the poems would be different in these new forms, it's crucial to support your ideas with evidence from the original poem. Cite specific lines or phrases that illustrate the potential changes in structure, style, or impact.