Inorganic Chemistry

Which one is more stable, [PCl4]+ or [PCl6]- ? Why?

I'm thinking it has something to do with the fact that the former is tetrahedral and the latter is octahedral, but I'm not sure. Does that affect stability?

  1. 0
  2. 23
asked by Arora
  1. [PCl4]^+ is sp3 which is a tetragedral shape; however, note that the electrons fit exactly; i.e., P = 5 and 4*7 = 28 for Cl for total of 33 for PCl4 or 32 for [PCl4]^+.

    For PCl6, it is octahedral which is d2sp3; however, adding an electron to make it [PCl6]^- adds an extra electron to an already filled d2sp3 and it really has no place to go. So I think the latter is less stable.
    See this site.
    https://www.google.com/search?q=lewis+stgructure+PCl4%5E%7C&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b-1

    1. 0
    posted by DrBob222

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Physics

    The following table gives values for the mass defect ∆m for four hypothetical nuclei: A, B, C, and D, isotopes of an element. ABCD Mass defect, ∆m(×10^-29 kg) A. B. C. D -6.0 -2.0 0 +6.0 Which statement is true regarding the
  2. chemistry

    (a) Consider the gaseous molecule BN-. At home, construct the molecular orbital diagram that is consistent with the known order of filling of molecular orbitals in the second period and with BN- being stable and paramagnetic. What
  3. Chemistry

    In a CH3CF2CHF2 molecule, which conformation is more stable and how much more is one stable than the other? I think Anti is more stable than gauche. I don't know why, I just think that a molecule is most stable in it's anti form.
  4. chemistry

    What hybrid orbitals are used by nitrogen and phosphorous atoms in the following species? (a) NH3, (b) PCl4+, (c) H2N-NH2
  5. Business

    Apply critical thinking to the decision making process by discussing workplace examples that highlight each of these three types of thinking...creative thinking, logical thinking, and persuasice thinking. Must be a minimum of 200
  6. Physics

    For each of the following functions describing the net force on a particle, determine any and all positions of equilibrium and characterize each as stable or unstable. (a) F = 4x − 2x3, (b) F = x2 + x − 6, (c) F = 5x − 9.
  7. chemistry

    bismuth of 209/83Bi is stable because? nuclei even or odd # of nucleons. which one is stable?
  8. Chemistry

    While I3- and Br3- are both stable molecules F3- is not a stable molecule. Provide an explanation.
  9. Astronomy

    Which of the following statements is correct? (check all that apply) If liquid water is not stable on the surface of Mars, liquid CO2 is definitely not stable. If liquid CO2 is not stable on the surface of Mars, liquid water is
  10. Chemistry

    Earlier I asked for a definition of non-volatile. Given the fact that it won't evaporate at all, does it mean that a non-volatile substance is stable in whatever state it is in at room temperature? Thanks again ahead of time Not

More Similar Questions