English

posted by rfvv today at 8:24am.



After we put an egg in a glass, when we add salt, the egg goes up from the bottom. Which of the following expressions is correct.

1. The egg is moving up from the bottom.
2. The egg is floating up from the bottom.
3. The egg is going up from the bottom.

[Which one is correct? Can we substitute 'upwards' for 'up'?]


English - Writeacher today at 8:36am
I take it you mean in a glass of water, right?

I think "floating" is probably the most accurate verb here, but all three verbs are correct.

You can use "upwards" rather than "up" if you wish, but it's not necessary.

------------------------------------
Thank you for your help. Yes, the egg is in a glass of water.

1. The egg is moving up from the bottom.
2. The egg is floating up from the bottom.
3. The egg is going up from the bottom.

4. The egg is floating.
5. The egg is floating on the surface of the water in the glass.

[Does #4 mean #1 or #5?]

Number 4, "The egg is floating," means the same thing as number 2, "The egg is floating up from the bottom." It implies that the egg is buoyant in the water and is resting at or near the water's surface. Number 1, "The egg is moving up from the bottom," does not specifically mention floating and could imply that the egg is moving through the water in some other way. Number 5, "The egg is floating on the surface of the water in the glass," is a more detailed description of the egg's position and clarifies that it is floating on the surface of the water in the glass.