philosophy (logic)

I need to know if these two statements are independent:

All winners are losers.
All losers are winners.

I am thinking that they are because I don't see that the truth or falsity of one tells anything about the truth or falsity of the other.

Also, if "Some Americans are children" is false, is the statement "Some nonchildren are nonAmericans" true, false, or undetermined.

I know that the statements are not logically equivalent, but I don't know what that says about the contrapositive in terms of truth value.

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 40
  1. I agree with your first statement.

    Your second statement about nonchildren would be undetermined.

    To use another example:

    Some bears are purple. (false)
    Some nonbears are not purple. (undetermined)

  2. sub+ob

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
    posted by debayan
  3. sub+ob=

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
    posted by debayan

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. macroeconomics

    The basis for international trade is that: a. a nation can import a particular good at a lower cost than if it were produced domestically. b. we stand to gain if we can sell more to other nations than they buy fro us c. there are

    asked by Carrigon on May 21, 2013
  2. math

    the disney golf classic starts with 64 golfers.the golfers form pairs and each pair plays a match.the losers drop out and the winners of each pair then form new pairs and play again.then those winners form pairs and play.this

    asked by quan tanksley on November 8, 2012
  3. math

    The disney Golf classic starts with 64 golfers. the golfes form pairs and each pair plays amtch. the losers drop out nad the winners of each pair then form new pairs and play again. Then those winners form pairs and play. this

    asked by Alejandro on May 1, 2011
  4. math

    the disney golf classic starts with 64 golfers. the golfers form pairs and each pair plays a match. the losers drop out and the winners of each pair then form new pairs and play again. then those winners form pairs and play. this

    asked by ciera on March 5, 2007
  5. Math

    Okay .. did you see my last answer? I think it is 5 But now I have another one and I think I know the answer but there is a trick question at the end. Maybe you can tell me if it is a trick or if it something I am missing. A golf

    asked by Emily on September 13, 2007
  6. english grammar

    Teambuilding consensus when team decisions have to be making it is very important that every member of the team at least can live with it. Everybody must have had the opportunity to mention his arguments and everybody must have

    asked by natty 6 on December 20, 2011
  7. reading

    the reason the test questions and answers is up there because its all wrong answers on purpose for cheaters. when i first started i passed two test by myself. then the last three test try to cheat to use the answers and failed

    asked by erica on July 9, 2012
  8. Pasta cars

    Okay, so my science assignment is to build a pasta car. There is a compitition between all of my teacher's classes, and the other team's science teacher's classes.--losers have to buy the winners a breakfast party. Awards go to

    asked by <3Medic+Droid<3 on February 2, 2009
  9. Psychology

    Why do you guys hate Ms. sue so much if it wasn't for her than half of you losers would have F's in your classes. She's a VOLUNTEER which means that she doesn't have to take any time out of her day to help you. So how about you

    asked by Ms. Sue Liker on November 9, 2015
  10. statistics

    A fast food chain claims that all of its quick win soda cups are winners. (There is a little tab you pull off the side of the cup which says either you are a winner or not. Lisa bought 8 sodas to try her luck. What is the

    asked by lola on March 23, 2012

More Similar Questions